Devon BrooksChoosing the right health insurance in Columbus can feel confusing, especially with so many plans to compare.
The right coverage helps you manage everyday healthcare costs, whether you’re filling prescriptions at pharmacies, booking routine checkups, or visiting gynecologists and other specialists.
With that in mind, I put together this guide to trusted local agencies that can help you find a plan that fits your needs and budget.
Keep reading to find coverage that gives you peace of mind!
How much does health insurance cost in Columbus?
Health insurance in Columbus typically costs $310 to over $800 per month for an individual without subsidies.
Your premium depends on the plan tier you choose, with Bronze plans offering lower monthly costs and Gold plans providing more comprehensive coverage with lower out-of-pocket expenses.
| Plan Tier | Average Monthly Cost (Unsubsidized) | Deductible and Premium Balance |
| Bronze | $310 to $520 | Lowest premiums with the highest deductibles |
| Silver | $410 to $720 | Moderate premiums and moderate deductibles |
| Gold | $540 to $800+ | Highest premiums with the lowest medical costs |
1. HealthMarkets Insurance: Chris Weible
Website: https://www.healthmarkets.com/
Address: 38 Dillmont Drive
Contact: 440-503-5248
Hours: Monday to Thursday 8:00 AM–9:00 PM, Friday 8:00 AM–5:00 PM, Saturday to Sunday Closed
HealthMarkets Insurance: Chris Weible helps clients find health and Medicare coverage that fits their budget.
Here, guidance is free and personalized, covering Affordable Care Act paperwork and enrollment steps to reduce confusion when comparing plans alone.
As an independent agency, they compare options from several top insurers rather than a single provider. This setup gives individuals, families, and small businesses access to health plans, supplemental coverage, and extra policy add-ons.
On the downside, plan availability depends on the specific carriers the agency represents in your area.
Additionally, off-marketplace plans do not qualify for federal tax subsidies available through the official exchange, which may increase out-of-pocket costs for some policyholders.
Clarity and Honest Guidance
Health Insurance??? If you want/need clarity in a space that’s often confusing, talk to Chris Weible. Chris takes the time to understand your needs and matches you with insurance solutions that truly fit. No pressure, just honest guidance and real care for the people he serves. If protecting your health, family, or business matters to you, Chris is someone you can trust. Call him today!
- Brett Oakley, Google Review
Above and Beyond on a Sunday Morning
I lost my health insurance not long ago and didn’t know what to do. I got a coupon from HealthMarkets in my Val Pak and thought I’d give them a call. Chris was wonderful, met me early on a Sunday morning and was so kind! He asked me what I wanted to spend per month and was able to get me insurance to fit my budget. I highly recommend him!!
- Marilyn Wade, Google Review
2. Exact Medicare: Medicare Plans
Website: https://www.exactmedicare.com/
Address: 550 Polaris Pkwy #510
Contact: 614- 503-1593
Hours: Monday to Friday 9:00 AM–5:00 PM, Saturday to Sunday Closed
Exact Medicare: Medicare Plans helps seniors and people with disabilities find coverage tailored to their specific needs. The agency provides personalized, one-on-one guidance to clarify complex options and make enrollment less stressful.
To help clients choose the right fit, advisors compare Medicare Supplement and Medicare Advantage plans side by side. Their evaluations cover prescription drug needs, total costs, and added benefits like dental and hearing care.
Clients also receive ongoing support through annual check-ins to ensure their coverage evolves alongside changing health requirements.
However, they team up with only eight groups, so some plans may be left out. Also, sign-up stays fixed to set windows, unless a client fits a Special Enrolment Period.
Patient, Clear, and Concise
Justin really helped me find an insurance plan that was appropriate for me. He was friendly, professional, clear, concise and made sure i understood the plans.
I really appreciated his patience and kindness and his knowledge of a multitude of health plans. Thank you!
- Holly Hall, Google Review
Excellent Over-the-Phone Support
I had an excellent experience receiving health insurance assistance over the phone. The representative, D Godfrey was patient, knowledgeable, and genuinely committed to helping me. I highly recommend their support to anyone needing guidance with health insurance.
- Harold P, Google Review
3. My Medicare Ohio
Website: https://www.mymedicareohio.com/
Address: 200 E Campus View Blvd STE 200
Contact: 888-644-6180
Hours: Available 24/7
My Medicare Ohio connects state residents with trained local agents to simplify the Medicare selection process at no cost.
Because these advisors are independent, they offer unbiased guidance tailored to each individual’s specific health needs and budget rather than representing a single insurance carrier.
To help clients choose the right fit, agents compare rates across multiple providers and walk through dual Medicare and Medicaid options to clarify complex choices. They also provide step-by-step support during initial enrollment and plan reviews.
Keep in mind that My Medicare Ohio is a private firm, not a federal or state government agency. Additionally, their consultations and advisory services are strictly limited to residents living in Ohio.
Stress-Free With Zero Sales Pressure
I found My Medicare Ohio when I was enrolling in Medicare for the first time and I was completely overwhelmed with my options. My Medicare Ohio connected me with an expert local to me in Tiffin , OH who was patient and kind and explained everything about Medicare to me step by step. The entire process to enroll in a Medicare Supplement plan was completely stress free. There was zero sales pressure that I’ve typically heard about insurance agents. I even walked away with a wonderful guidebook to help me prepare for the yearly annual enrollment period later this year.
- Laura Schultz, Google Review
Proactive Local Resources
My Medicare Ohio helped me navigate the Medicare enrollment process. While working in Columbus and living in Chillicothe, they were able to connect me with local resources. I appreciate their proactive approach and review services.
- Bill M, Google Review
4. Impact Insurance Agency
Website: http://www.impactinsagency.com/
Address: 111 Commerce Park Drive
Contact: 614-324-2641
Hours: Monday to Friday 9:00 AM–5:00 PM, Saturday to Sunday Closed
Impact Insurance Agency helps individuals and businesses evaluate health coverage options with plans designed to meet diverse financial and medical needs.
For individuals, choices include Affordable Care Act Marketplace policies and short-term health insurance plans.
For employers, the agency provides structured corporate solutions, including Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangements (ICHRAs), level-funded group health plans, and supplemental benefits such as cancer, accident, and critical illness coverage.
These options give business owners the flexibility to build competitive benefit packages that provide meaningful, day-to-day health care support for their employees.
Just a heads up: before requesting a consultation, sending your info lets auto calls or set messages reach you. Follow-ups may still happen even if your number sits on the federal Do Not Call list.
Clear and Compassionate Support
Cheryl Johnson at Impact Insurance Agency is a true professional. She takes the time to understand individual needs and provides clear, personalized guidance through the complexities of insurance options. Whether it’s health, life, Medicare, or supplemental coverage, Cheryl’s expertise and dedication make the process straightforward and stress-free. Highly recommend her for anyone seeking knowledgeable and compassionate insurance support.
- Nathan Snoke, Google Review
A Great Proactive Resource
Cheryl Johnson and her team at Impact Insurance Agency have done a great job representing my wife and me in our insurance needs for Medicare and Supplemental insurance. They are professional and very proactive. A great resource to have in navigating the complex realm of health care insurance.
- Rhett Huddle, Google Review
5. Hyers & Associates Insurance
Website: https://www.ohioinsureplan.com/
Address: 240 Collins Avenue
Contact: 1-888-901-5650
Hours: Monday to Friday 8:30 AM–5:00 PM
Hyers & Associates Insurance helps clients evaluate coverage choices using rate review tools and policy discount checks to simplify the decision-making process.
The agency evaluates policy options across Health Savings Accounts (HSAs), Affordable Care Act (ACA) plans, Medicare, and Medigap coverage.
To make transitions seamless, advisors verify doctor and hospital networks during consultations, helping policyholders keep their preferred healthcare providers without interruption.
However, you must know that certain dental and vision policies include mandatory waiting periods before full coverage begins.
These plan limitations can delay access to specific benefits, making it important to review policy details carefully before enrolling to avoid unexpected out-of-pocket expenses.
Phenomenal Knowledge from Start to Finish
Mr Adam Hyers knowledge of health insurance applications as well as information is phenomenal. I worked with him for 2 years and he was able to answer every question or concerns I had. First I had Oscar, then when I turned 65 I received Medicare and Medicare supplement. As you all know filling out the applications on your own can be challenging but thanks to Adam Hyers of Hyers & Associates Insurance, everything went smoothly. I could not have done it all without his help.
- Cherri Bradshaw, Google Review
The Right Expert in Your Corner
Adam has helped and advised me with my health insurance needs for several years. His years of experience and knowledge have been wonderful. He helped me choose a health insurance plan that has served me well. Today, Adam, helped me navigate though Medicare options and decide on a plan. He is the person that you want in your corner when making these difficult decisions.
- Mark Morgan, Google Review
