Jordan EllisIf you’re anything like me, a perfect evening involves a sizzling, beautifully marbled cut of beef that practically melts in your mouth.
Finding the best steakhouse in Columbus can feel like a daunting task since our city has quite a few amazing spots vying for your attention. Whether you want a lively place to grab some drinks with friends or a quiet corner for a romantic date night, the right ambiance makes all the difference.
I love exploring the vibrant lineup of restaurants in Columbus to see who truly delivers on flavor, texture, and hospitality. Let’s dive into the absolute top spots that you need to visit next.
How much does steakhouse dining cost in Columbus?
A standard dinner at a local steakhouse typically ranges from a casual meal to a high-end, multi-course feast.
| Dining Style | Estimated Price Range | What It Includes |
| Casual or Family-Friendly | $15 – $30 | Great standard steak cuts |
| Upscale or Fine Dining | $40 – $100+ | Premium cuts, imported Wagyu, dry-aged tomahawks |
| Full Fine Dining Experience | $75 – $150+ per person | Steaks, drinks, appetizers, and sides |
1. Jeff Ruby’s Steakhouse
Website: http://jeffruby.com/columbus
Address: 89 E Nationwide Blvd
Contact: 614-686-7800
Hours:
Monday to Thursday: 4:30 PM – 9:00 PM
Friday to Saturday: 4:30 PM – 10:00 PM
Sunday: 4:30 PM – 8:30 PM
If you’re craving a night of pure luxury with premium steaks and exclusive cigar offerings, this downtown destination is a fantastic choice.
Jeff Ruby’s Steakhouse delivers an upscale dining experience crafted by founder Jeff Ruby. They feature high-end beef alongside a dedicated Ruby Wine Vault.
On my last visit, the server guided us perfectly through the wine selections, making the entire dinner feel incredibly special.
The kitchen also serves an extensive sushi menu that offers an incredible alternative to traditional appetizers before your main course arrives.
A notable downside is that you can’t order takeout on weekdays, which is a bit disappointing if you want a cozy Tuesday night at home. The restaurant has shorter dining hours on Sundays, too.
Still, the vibrant atmosphere makes dressing up and dining in completely worth it.
Customer Reviews:
One of the best
Jeff Ruby is one of the best steakhouses in the country. Every visit is uniformly great. Beautiful space, food is always top notch, our server tonight, Jordan was the best. We started with the complimentary bread with butter and an incredible truffle butter. Next,
our party of four shared appetizers of crab cakes, oyster Rockefeller, and an A5 ribeye. All perfectly prepared. My son and I shared the 70 days aged Cowboy steak for our entrees and apple sorbet and the best crème brûlée in town. We highly recommend Jeff Ruby!
Michael Chan | Google Review
Service here is of the highest level
Our first time at Jeff Ruby’s, it was a delicious and elevated experience. Definitely one of the best quality steaks of my life. I ordered the steak Burrow which was blackened and they still managed to nail a perfect medium rare. The steaks were flavorful and tender. Sauces and sides were yummy and the service here is of the highest level, yet not overly stuffy. We enjoyed a cozy early Birthday dinner and we’ll be back to celebrate other special occasions and explore the seafood options.
Donna Arnold | Google Review
2. Butcher & Rose
Website: https://butcherandrose.com/
Address: 155 E Broad St
Contact: 614.918.9819
Hours:
Lunch
Monday to Friday: 11:30 AM – 3:00 PM
Dinner
Monday to Thursday: 3:00 PM – 9:00 PM
Friday: 3:00 PM – 10:00 PM
Saturday: 4:00 PM – 10:00 PM | Sunday: 4:00 PM – 9:00 PM
Finding a fresh, modern twist on classic steak dinners is easy at this gorgeous venue on East Broad Street.
Founded by famous restaurateur Cameron Mitchell, Butcher & Rose provides a playful steakhouse experience highlighted by exclusive beverage collaborations like the Essentiel champagne blend.
You can enjoy a luxurious Wagyu flight tasting option inside a signature glass dining room called The Pavillion, which features beautiful hanging greenery. The stunning atmosphere makes it a spectacular destination for any celebratory meal.
A close friend also told me that the custom floral and valet services made their private event here feel completely seamless.
But one minor drawback is that the restaurant opens an hour later on weekends, which cuts into early afternoon dining plans.
Customer Reviews:
Food was great
Jennifer was a wonderful server. Patio was beautiful for a date night. Food was great, cocktails were beautiful and flavorful. We had the dirty tots and bread for an appetizer. Butcher and rose cocktails. Mac n cheese steak and Wellington for dinner. Creme brulee for dessert.
Valet was $15 for dinner.
Ting Ting Tiao | Google Review
Recommended
Wonderful experience ! Server was very kind and informative. Went over everything on the menu and even asked about dietary restrictions. The Tomahawk steak and Mac & cheese were delicious! Would recommend to anyone in Columbus to visit.
Dillon Randleman | Google Review
3. Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse
Website: https://www.hydeparkrestaurants.com/location/downtown-columbus/
Address: 569 North High Street
Contact: (614) 224-2204
Hours:
Monday to Thursday: 4:30 PM – 9:00 PM
Friday to Saturday: 4:30 PM – 10:00 PM
Sunday: 4:00 PM – 8:00 PM
Serious beef connoisseurs will find a fantastic haven at Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse. This restaurant stands out with its specialized boutique beef program that procures rare global cuts, including Japanese A5, on their dedicated Wagyu menu.
They also pay homage to local culture by naming specialty steaks after Ohio sports legends like Urban Meyer.
Guests who come here can gather in a private wine room equipped with an open kitchen or explore a curated rare spirits flight program featuring over-proofed whiskeys.
The exceptional cuts and lively energy make every single visit highly rewarding.
On the downside, the surrounding area gets quite busy, meaning you might have to opt for valet parking at an extra cost. Planning ahead for traffic is also smart.
Customer Reviews:
Delicious!
My wife spotted Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse down from Ruth chris Steakhouse, and she wanted to give them a try. We are so glad we did! Excellent service! Amazing atmosphere and delicious food! We shared the 26 0z Ryan day dry aged ribeye. Delicious! 😋 We also shared the cheesy potatoes… Delicious! 😋 And we shared a salad 🥗 absolutely tasty 😋. 5 STARS 🌟 Frist time in Columbus, Ohio, and we struck gold dining at Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse! Thank you! Chris and Wendy from Michigan.
Christopher Van Buren | Google Review
Beyond expectation
My wife and I went here for our 35th anniversary. From the hostess stand to everyone in the restaurant service was top notch. Especially AJ our server. He was phenomenal. Management and everyone came by our table to wish us happy anniversary. My wife had lamb chops and I had aged ribeye. Both were beyond expectation. My wife and I agree this was our new best ever meal. Thanks AJ and the rest of the staff.
Michael Adair | Google Review
4. J. Gilbert’s Wood Fired Steaks & Seafood Columbus
Website: https://www.jgilberts.com/location/jgilberts-columbus/
Address: 1 E Campus View Blvd
Contact: (614) 840-9090
Hours:
Sunday to Thursday: 4:00 PM – 9:00 PM
Friday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Saturday: 4:00 PM – 10:00 PM
If you appreciate the deep, smoky flavor that only an open fire can provide, Gilbert’s Wood Fired Steaks & Seafood is an excellent choice.
Named in tribute to legendary restaurateur Joe Gilbert, the restaurant serves excellent Midwestern-raised, United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) Prime Black Angus beef cooked exclusively over an open mesquite wood-fire grill.
I love how the kitchen supports local farmers by offering locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. Plus, they stick to true Midwestern value by including delicious side dishes alongside your steak entrees.
A small downside is that the restaurant only serves lunch once a week on Fridays, so weekday midday dining is limited. But the incredible wood-fired char and packaged seafood boil kits make this place a phenomenal choice for dinner.
Customer Reviews:
Best steak ever
Wife and son said best steak ever, even better than mine.
I had the sea bass. It was amazing. First time eating Bass. All sides were also amazing. This restaurant from when you walk in the door till you leave the door is high class without the guest dress code.
Michael Taylor | Google Review
Steak was delicious
Me and my fiancee decided to have a date night. I made reservations and am so glad I did. We ordered the 3 course meal. The steak was delicious! Everything was amazing. The lobster mac and cheese and carrot cake was awesome. The shrimp was a little rubbery but other than that it was a great experience. I definitely look forward to eating here again.
Heather | Google Review
5. Eddie Merlot’s
Website: https://www.eddiemerlots.com/columbus/
Address: 1570 Polaris Pkwy
Contact: (614) 433-7307
Hours:
LUNCH
Monday – Friday: 11:00 AM – 3:00 PM
DINNER
Sunday – Thursday: 3:00 PM – 9:00 PM
Friday – Saturday: 3:00 PM – 10:00 PM
For anyone looking to host a grand celebration or simply enjoy an expertly aged cut of meat, this contemporary American spot on Polaris Parkway delivers.
Eddie Merlot’s stands out with its exceptional prime beef that’s hand-cut in-house and aged for a minimum of 28 days to maximize flavor and tenderness. They also host regular wine pairing dinners to ensure there’s always an incredible reason to visit.
They provide a massive private dining infrastructure with beautiful spaces like the Merlot and Cabernet rooms. On top of that, you can take advantage of fully customizable catering services in Columbus tailored perfectly for weddings and corporate events.
Just keep in mind that the lunch menu isn’t available on weekends, which might disrupt a midday Saturday gathering.
Customer Reviews:
One of the best places to eat steak in Ohio
Food here is always amazing. Ive eaten here several times and it’s finally time to say that this is one of the best places to eat steak in ohio. It’s a good in the middle of high end steak and a good price. Service here has NEVER been an issue. Always very well taken care of.
1 (Wolfie23) | Google Review
Steak was cooked perfect
Took the wife out on a date to finally try this place. It didn’t disappoint….so many things on the menu I wanted to try. Steak was cooked perfect and had great flavor. The calamari was good and the sauces they provided were a good opposite to enjoy sweet and spicy. Brussel sprouts were good but not great. The wife said the salad was the best she’s had. Got the peanut butter pie for desert which was rich and creamy. Look forward to coming back and giving it a try.
bryan rooth | Google Review
