Maya RichardsonUpgrading a bedroom should feel exciting, but finding the right support can still get overwhelming. Before you focus on hiring local painting services or handling mold removal for a bedroom refresh, start with the thing you use every night: your mattress.
Whether you’re settling into a new space or shopping on a budget, the right sleep setup can change your whole routine.
I put together this guide to the best mattresses in Columbus so you can compare local options without getting buried in sales talk.
How much do mattresses cost in Columbus?
Mattresses in Columbus typically cost $120 for basic entry-level models to more than $1,500 for specialized beds, so shoppers can find a comfortable setup at several price points.
| Quality Level | Average Price Range (Full/Queen) | Common Features |
| Budget | $100 – $400 | Basic innerspring, 8-10 inch memory foam, bed-in-a-box |
| Mid-Range | $400 – $900 | Higher-quality hybrids, 12-inch+ memory foam, better edge support |
| Premium | $900+ | Specialized materials, name-brand sets |
1. The Original Mattress Factory
Website: https://www.originalmattress.com/
Address: 851 West 5th Avenue
Contact: (614) 291-8085
Hours: Monday-Friday, 10:00 AM – 8:00 PM; Saturday, 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM; Sunday, 12:00 PM – 5:00 PM
Shopping for a bed often involves navigating confusing retail markups, but cutting out the middleman changes the game entirely.
By building their inventory in local factories and selling directly to the public, The Original Mattress Factory (OMF) passes on significant savings right at the baseline price.
They also specialize in traditional two-sided, flippable beds to help extend the lifespan of your purchase through even wear.
I recently stopped by to check out their genuine shock-absorbing box springs, and the lack of aggressive commission pressure made the visit incredibly refreshing.
The staff encouraged me to take my time testing different firmness levels without hovering.
While their transparency is great, keep in mind that their stripped-down everyday pricing means they don’t waive standard delivery fees.
You will need to budget for non-negotiable shipping costs if you cannot haul it home yourself.
I highly recommend it to anyone.
I had to get rid of a mattress set I had for about 15 years due to pest issues. Had heard about OMF thru ads and visited the business. Felt very comfy with the store manager Rick who guided me through how their product is made and pricing. Bought a new mattress set and am VERY happy I did. Delivery was very efficient. Highly recommend to anyone in the market for new bedding
- Jay Reyes | Google Review
Their prices are fantastic.
Simply the best. With every terrible bed in a box mattress I’ve tried, there’s something to be said about heavily warrantied, classically constructed beds. Compared to big box brands, their prices are fantastic. That guy Rick that works there is exceptionally patient and nice. Would recommend to anyone. Been sleeping on their products for decades.
- Steve Williams | Google Review
2. Mattress Warehouse of Central Ohio
Website: https://mattresswarehousecentralohio.com/
Address: 60 Grace Drive, Suite A, Powell
Contact: (614) 468-3070
Hours: Available 24/7
Securing a high-end luxury bed on a tight budget is entirely possible when you shop through a high-volume liquidator.
Mattress Warehouse of Central Ohio specializes in acquiring massive factory overstocks and discontinued models, allowing them to offer name brands for a fraction of the usual cost.
Budget-conscious shoppers can grab a heavy discount and immediately load the inventory onto their truck the same day. They also host truckload events that bring in fresh shipments for eager bargain hunters.
If you lack a large vehicle, they coordinate rapid same-day local delivery to get you set up before nightfall.
The major downside to this liquidation model is highly unpredictable inventory. If you find a specific firmness you love on the floor, it might be the last one available and cannot be special-ordered in another size directly from the manufacturer.
Way less than we would have paid at a traditional retail store!
My wife Jill and I had a fantastic experience today! Monika thoroughly explained the different mattress options and what we should be looking for in terms of support. Plus, we now have independent adjustability and can even choose different sheets! All this for way less than we would have paid at a traditional retail store! If you are in need of a new mattress, I would highly recommend Monika and her team at Mattress Warehouse of Central Ohio!
- Adam Lightfoot | Google Review
Her prices are the best in town.
We purchased a mattress last Saturday and Monika provided amazing customer service. She is extremely knowledgeable about mattress construction as well as very tentative to your needs. Her prices are the best in town. I would not consider purchasing a mattress at any other store.
- RYfT jesus | Google Review
3. Mattress Firm Lennox Station
Website: https://www.mattressfirm.com/
Address: 1430 Olentangy River Road
Contact: (614) 299-2064
Hours: Monday-Saturday, 10:00 AM – 8:00 PM; Sunday, 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Testing out multiple national brands side by side saves you the headache of driving all over the city.
Mattress Firm Lennox Station works like a large comparison hub. They let you compare major competitors in one convenient room while backing your choice with a 120-night sleep trial.
Their trained staff use specialized profiling technology to ask targeted questions about your sleeping position and narrow down the overwhelming showroom.
They also carry a huge inventory of accessories like cooling pillows and adjustable bases.
If the bed fails to resolve your back pain after a few months, you can exchange it for a different model.
However, actually executing a return or exchange during that trial period usually incurs non-refundable restocking and return delivery charges.
I will be referring everyone to this mattress firm.
First time at this location and the experience was awesome! Sleep experts Jason and Keith were amazing. They helped me choose a mattress that best fit my preferences. Jason was very knowledgeable about all the inventory and Keith matched his expertise w/ added confirmation and kindness. They were very refreshing and I will be referring everyone to this mattress firm.
- Sherrie Singletary | Google Review
Genuinely focused on helping me find the right mattress.
Jason at Mattress Firm was outstanding to work with. He was knowledgeable, patient, and genuinely focused on helping me find the right mattress, not just making a sale. He took the time to explain the differences between options, listened to what I was looking for, and made the whole process easy and stress-free. I never felt pressured, and his professionalism really stood out. If you’re shopping at Mattress Firm, I highly recommend asking for Jason.
- Jasmine Dunlap | Google Review
4. Sleep Outfitters of Columbus Gemini
Website: https://sleepoutfitters.com/
Address: 1516 Gemini Pl
Contact: (614) 436-4115 | [email protected]
Hours: Monday-Saturday, 10:00 AM – 8:00 PM; Sunday, 12:00 PM – 6:00 PM
Figuring out exactly why you are waking up tired is much easier when you go through a formalized sleep assessment first.
Sleep Outfitters of Columbus Gemini curates its showroom around an exclusive partnership with Sealy and Stearns & Foster, so the staff knows those heritage lines well.
I recently accompanied a friend here to replace her old setup, and the pristine, climate-controlled environment felt completely relaxing. Their team hauled away her sagging bed and fully set up the new frame, which made the transition feel seamless.
On top of that, they protect your investment with a 120-night comfort promise and a solid price match guarantee.
The main drawback is their restricted brand variety because they focus on their exclusive retail partnerships. You will not find competing luxury brands to physically test against in the same building.
Great high quality mattresses!
Steve was so kind and helpful! He helped us find exactly what we were looking for! Great high quality mattresses too! The 300 dollar credit to get a mattress protector was a perfect incentive as well. I will definitely be returning for pillows!
- Veronica Lee | Google Review
We ended up buying a mattress!
Had a great experience at Sleep Outfitters! We came in just to look and ended up buying a mattress! Steve was very knowledgeable and helped make the process easy, asked questions about how we sleep and what we were looking for to help us pick the right mattress. You spend a 1/3 of your life in a bed so I highly recommend seeing Steve and making the most of your sleep!
- Chloe Good | Google Review
5. Midwest Mattress and Furniture Outlet
Website: http://www.midwestmattressandfurnitureoutlet.com/
Address: 3823 South High Street
Contact: (614) 813-3382
Hours: Monday & Wednesday-Friday, 2:00 PM – 6:00 PM; Saturday, 11:00 AM – 3:00 PM; Sunday, 1:00 PM – 4:00 PM
Moving into a new apartment often requires outfitting multiple rooms on a strict budget, which makes a hybrid discount center incredibly useful.
Midwest Mattress and Furniture Outlet operates as a low-overhead warehouse, stripping away fancy marketing to provide wholesale-level pricing directly to the public.
They guarantee every item is brand new in the factory plastic, completely avoiding unsanitary refurbished returns.
Their setup allows renters to bundle cheap beds with living room sectionals in a single transaction without dealing with aggressive, commission-hungry salespeople.
The warehouse is packed with accessible inventory, encouraging you to pay cash and load up your vehicle immediately.
The biggest challenge is navigating their highly restricted operating hours. They only open for a few hours each afternoon and close completely on Tuesdays, which can make weekday visits difficult for standard corporate employees.
Definitely cheaper than buying in a regular store
I’m glad I found this place, I managed to make an appointment the same day, we were looking for a mattress for our daughter’s room, they have many options of various prices definitely cheaper than buying in a regular store, the truth we were very happy with our purchase I recommend it, plus we already know where to go if we want to buy furniture.
- Paula Gutierrez | Google Review
We even discussed the price and agreed on my budget plan.
I came in looking for a extra firm mattress n got what I really wanted. We even discussed price and agreed for my budget plan. I liked the business he gave me and his customer service was excited 😊 …
- Alaxius Fields | Google Review
