Devon BrooksFeel like online ads are only a short-term solution to your business or organization? Yes, they can help a great deal when done right. But you can’t rely on them alone forever. You’ll need to do the dirty work to make your site visible on the search engine.
I thought this would be an easy feat because I’ve been writing blogs for so long. Why would I need to hire anyone else? But then, my website keeps getting stuck on page 2 on Google, and my ads have been draining my money with poor results.
Since I can’t lose more money without direction, I made it my mission to look for the best SEO experts in Columbus to audit my website. Whether you’re a freelancer, business owner, or organization head, here’s a review of my top picks below.
1. wowbrands
Address: 1550 Old Henderson Rd Ste S-205, Columbus, OH 43220, United States
Phone: +16147255345
Business Hours: Monday – Friday: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Search visibility is a central part of wowbrands’ digital marketing offering, with SEO strategies designed to help Rent-to-Own businesses attract more relevant visitors. The agency focuses on valuable keywords and combines broader SEO work with ongoing local search strategies.
Its SEO approach aims to establish keyword rankings that can help businesses compete within their markets. The emphasis on local SEO is particularly relevant for businesses seeking to attract nearby customers through organic search.
wowbrands describes its local SEO strategies and tactics as a way to drive high-quality organic traffic to client websites. The intended outcome is to turn people searching online into customers and, ultimately, generate more rentals for Rent-to-Own businesses.
SEO also works alongside the agency’s other digital marketing services, including ecommerce websites, paid search, promotional campaigns, and email marketing. This creates a broader marketing setup in which organic search can support the website and other customer-acquisition activities.
The agency’s specialization in Rent-to-Own is an important part of its SEO offering. Its client feedback specifically highlights an understanding of the industry’s nuances, suggesting that its approach is tailored toward businesses operating within this sector.
wowbrands also reports that its Rent-to-Own clients have experienced increases in site traffic, local rankings, and leads, along with more rentals. These stated results position SEO as part of a wider effort to improve both visibility and customer acquisition.
For Rent-to-Own businesses that want SEO combined with other digital marketing capabilities, wowbrands offers a specialized option. Its focus on keywords, local search, organic traffic, and lead generation makes the service particularly suited to businesses looking to strengthen their presence in relevant search results.
2. The Real Social Company
Address: Columbus, OH
Phone: +16144822126
Business Hours: Monday – Thursday: 9:00 AM – 3:00 PM; Friday – Sunday: Closed
The Real Social Company’s SEO Pros service is built around improving search visibility for medical, wellness, professional, and local service businesses. Its approach combines traditional SEO with Local SEO, AEO, and GEO, aiming to help businesses appear in organic results, Google Maps, local searches, and AI-driven search experiences.
A key focus is creating websites that support search performance from the ground up. The company builds custom React websites with structured content, schema, semantic markup, treatment-focused architecture, and responsive designs intended to support speed, accessibility, and search engine readability.
Its SEO offering also includes ongoing monitoring and guided optimization through the Website + Growth plan. Weekly audits can check for issues such as broken links, missing titles and descriptions, duplicate content, indexing problems, schema errors, weak internal linking, and other technical or content-related gaps, with larger recommended changes reviewed before implementation.
Local SEO is another significant part of the service, particularly for businesses that depend on nearby customers. The company focuses on geographic search visibility, Google Maps, local results, and near-me searches, while also supporting multiple locations and structured information about providers, services, and locations.
The service is especially tailored to healthcare and wellness businesses, including medical spas, wellness clinics, mental health practices, hormone and weight-loss clinics, and medical practices. The company says it has been building websites since 2002 and handles SEO, AEO, and GEO in-house, with ongoing helpdesk support and direct involvement from its team.
The Real Social Company also connects SEO with broader digital marketing activities rather than treating search optimization as an isolated service. Depending on the plan, this can include ongoing AEO and GEO optimization, four monthly blog posts, email marketing campaigns, advertising strategy and creative, conversion tracking, monthly reporting, and website management.
Businesses that want an integrated search and website strategy may find this approach suitable, particularly when patient education, local discovery, and AI search visibility are important. The service is closely aligned with practices that want their website, content, technical SEO, local presence, and ongoing optimization handled as part of one connected system.
I highly recommend them!
“I’ve really enjoyed working with The Real Social Company. What I appreciate most is their responsiveness and commitment to their clients. Anytime I had a question or an issue, the owner personally responded and made sure it was addressed. That level of accessibility and customer service makes a huge difference. I highly recommend them!”
-Louisana Louis, Google Review
Depth of knowledge are exceptional
“I’ve been working with Joe at The Real Social Company and I can honestly say he has exceeded every expectation. His attention to detail, flexibility, and depth of knowledge are exceptional—but what truly sets him apart is his ability to consistently execute and get things done at a high level.
As a business owner for over 10 years, I’ve worked with many marketing professionals, and Joe stands out as one of the most dedicated and detail-oriented individuals I’ve come across. He takes ownership, communicates clearly, and genuinely cares about delivering results.
Highly recommend Joe and the Real Social Company to anyone looking to elevate their marketing with someone who truly goes above and beyond.”
-David Rosner, Google Review
3. Kow Abundant
Address: 1071 Fishinger Rd #109, WorkSPACE
Phone: +1 614 230 2308, [email protected]
Business hours:
- Mon-Fri: 10:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Sat-Sun: Closed
What I like about Kow Abundant is that it’s an SEO company in Columbus known for its affordable fees that can cater to many small businesses. It even offers bundles combining Google Ads and SEO management to make things simpler for newbies.
Another thing I appreciate is that the team doesn’t put a lot of pressure on its clients to sign with them long-term. You can pause your campaigns at any time because you can choose not to have a binding contract. For me, this makes the team more trustworthy.
Not only that, but I also love the team’s complimentary SEO assessment using SEMrush—a tool that can be used to audit your site.
You can also get its help with SEO link building, listings management, and competitor tracking to ensure an advantage over others.
However, this company seems to have a small team. I reckon this can limit its capacity to handle many big campaigns.
Very Helpful
“Very helpful in managing website development and online visibility for businesses. Responsive in listening to customers needs.”
-Mr. Erik Hrabowy, Google Review
Very Impressed
“I was very impressed with Kow Abundant. We were seeing significant results as soon as our second month. Great partnership.”
-Mr. Scott Baker, Google Review
4. SEO Titan Web Design Company
Address: 79 Spruce St
Phone: +1 614 420 2641
Business hours:
- Mon-Fri: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Sat: 9:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Sun: Closed
Not only is SEO Titan Web Design Company great at SEO strategies, but I also admire how good its team is at creating attractive websites that can boost conversions and sales!
I like that for this company, having a pretty website is only the bare minimum. It adds many innovative features that can engage visitors and motivate them to click your call-to-action button.
And if you need more memorable visuals, it’s handy that the team can also make custom signage and other branding materials.
Apart from the websites, you can also opt for the company’s e-commerce solutions, mobile app development, and social media marketing to make your other supporting strategies more effective.
But due to its service scale and complexity, I think this company might be less focused on lower-cost projects or smaller businesses. Still, I think the consultation is worth a shot, though.
Traffic Keeps Growing
“My traffic keeps growing steadily. That’s the impact of their SEO services, while the website design helps visitors stay and explore more.”
-Ms. Lindsay Jackson, Google Review
So Thrilled
“I’m thrilled with the results from their seo company. My site is now ranking, and I’m attracting the right customers.”
-Mr. Dalton, Google Review
5. Two Wheels Marketing
Address: 875 N High St 4th floor, The Offices at The Sutton
Phone: +1 614 440 4020
Business hours:
- Mon-Fri: 8:00 AM – 5:30 PM
- Sat-Sun: Closed
Two Wheels Marketing specializes in many things, including PPC, paid social ads, and SEO in Columbus. What I admire most about this company is that it shares many case studies to prove its excellence in the industry.
One of its most notable works for me was when it helped a floral company with multiple locations increase its monthly revenue more than 10 times over! This is within just 2 years too, so I think the team has been quite effective and efficient with this business.
I’m also impressed that this agency has premier Google Partner status. For me, this certification reflects its strong expertise in the field.
Yet, I couldn’t see a lot of information when it comes to its service tiers. No clear indication of bundles or special deals either, so you’ll have to reach out directly for a proper quote.
Spot-On Communication
“I have enjoyed working with Two Wheels marketing. They not only have increased my profits buts they have made the process of setting up everything very easy. Their communication is spot on, quick to respond and send monthly reports on time.”
-Ms. Annette LaRocque, Google Review
Best Sales Results Ever
“As the owner of a busy retail Florist (brick and mortar and online) we love the way Two Wheels manages our marketing program. From SEO to Social Platforms, we have seen the best sales results since we have been under contract with them. Mark and Ryan are results driven, easy to reach, flexible and always transparent!!”
-Ms. Wendy Rockcastle, Google Review
6. The Media Captain
Address: 394 E Town St
Phone: +1 614 564 9313, [email protected]
Business hours:
- Mon-Fri: 8:30 AM – 5:00 PM
- Sat-Sun: Closed
The Media Captain is a sibling-owned SEO agency in Columbus that’s been in the business since 2010. Besides SEO, it can assist you with paid ads, email marketing, social media, web and graphic design, and user experience.
I think its team hit the right balance when it comes to size. Not too big or too small—it can handle all its projects well and has all its key resources in-house.
It’s amazing for me that it has worked with big names too, such as the Schottenstein Real Estate Group, Hughston Clinic, and Boss Gal Beauty Bar. For me, this also showcases its flexibility with different industries.
Another factor that I believe adds to its credibility is being voted a Top 1% Agency in the US by UpCity. It was also named a Top 1000 B2B Company Globally by Clutch.
Yet, a client I approached told me about a delay in its reporting speed one time. While this can be a one-off scenario, I believe the team can still improve in this aspect, especially for businesses that need urgent updates the most.
Fantastic Job
“Fantastic job building our new website. Massive improvement over our old site in every way. Process was smooth and easy. Can’t think of anything they could improve”
-Mr. Joseph DiPaolo, Google Review
Helped Us Tremendously
“The Media Captain has been wonderful work with and they have helped our company tremendously with website, SEO and many other marketing/advertising related items.”
-Mr. Drew Knoesel, Google Review
7. FYVE Marketing
Address: 875 N High St 4th floor Suite 53, The Offices at The Sutton
Phone: +1 614 362 4480, [email protected]
Business hours:
- Mon-Fri: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Sat-Sun: Closed
FYVE Marketing is located right in the heart of Columbus, so I bet you can easily talk to its team in person if you prefer on-site meetings.
Aside from SEO, this company offers website design and development, social media marketing, content and email marketing, and local PR (public relations).
It’s also refreshing for me that its team doesn’t believe in spouting buzzwords. The SEO pros here make sure the clients truly understand their reports in simpler terms for seamless communication.
Other than that, I’m stoked that several of the case studies in its online portfolio are all about local Columbus businesses meeting their goals of ranking higher in Google. Notable ones are Taneff Law, Prim Painting, and Magnetic Springs.
That said, one client I talked to mentioned an issue about the team having some difficulty managing larger budgets, mostly in ads. I personally think this could be a rare issue, but I still recommend having an open line to avoid any misunderstandings.
Outstanding Job
“FYVE marketing has been extremely helpful. Caitlin has done an outstanding job in building us a new website. You’re in good hands with FYVE marketing.”
-Ms. Elisha Jackson, Google Review
Excellent to Work With
“Fyve has been an excellent company to work with! We’ve seen incredible result since switching to their marketing strategies. Highly recommend!!!”
-Mr. Kyle Kellner, Google Review
