Jordan EllisThat craving for warm pita, slow-roasted meats, and tangy tzatziki hits hard, and a so-so gyro just won’t cut it.
If you want rich, authentic flavors, hunting down the best Greek restaurants in Columbus is a great place to start. The local food scene is full of cozy spots cooking up family recipes that make you feel like you’re on an island in the Aegean Sea.
Many of these local restaurants also offer great catering services for big family gatherings.
So here’s a close look at the top spots in town serving incredible gyros and fresh tzatziki.
How much does it cost to eat at a Greek restaurant in Columbus?
Eating at a Greek restaurant in Columbus typically costs between $7 for a quick pita lunch and $35 for a full sit-down dinner with specialty plates.
| Dining Style | Price Range |
| Quick-service and pita joints | $7 to $12 |
| Combo meals with sides | $12 to $16 |
| Casual platters and bowls | $14 to $16 |
| Sit-down dinner entrees | $15 to $25 |
| Specialty plates and lamb chops | $25 to $35 |
| Appetizers and small plates | $7 to $11 |
1. The Mad Greek
Website: madgreektogo.com
Address: 4210 E Broad St
Contact: (614) 338-0000
Hours: Monday to Thursday, 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM; Friday and Saturday, 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM; Sunday, 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM
The Mad Greek focuses on authentic dishes rooted in time-tested recipes, leaning on fresh, locally sourced ingredients for their signature Mediterranean gyros.
Craving traditional meals made from scratch leads many local food fans straight to this spot on East Broad Street. You can also explore a huge menu that stretches from hearty bowls to classic pasta platters.
My coworker recently dined here and mentioned that the slow-roasted meats paired beautifully with the famous homemade desserts. The portions are also generous and satisfying.
That said, the kitchen sometimes struggles with consistency, so you might occasionally get a gyro wrap with a soggy texture.
Side dishes can also fall short during a chaotic weekend rush.
Customer Reviews
The pistachio cake is divine
In town for business and stopped by for some Greek food. This restaurant makes me want to move here just to be able to eat here often. The food is delicious and the staff is so welcoming. Don’t leave until you have added the pistachio cake to your meal. It is divine!
– Christy Moore | Google Review
Good food, good portions, good service
This is, hands down, some of the best food I’ve had. I was nervous to try a new restaurant, but this place blew it out of the water. The stuffed mushrooms were fire and the Greek fries were bangin. Me? Stuffed. Good food, good portions, good service. I will be telling everyone to go here.
– Checkeredclef Edber | Google Review
2. King Gyros Greek Restaurant
Website: kinggyros.com
Address: 400 South Hamilton Road, Whitehall
Contact: (614) 866-9008
Hours: Monday to Friday, 10:30 AM to 10:00 PM; Saturday, 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM
King Gyros is fully Greek-owned and dishes out traditional family recipes made from scratch using vibrant ingredients. Knowing their proud Food Network pedigree changes your expectations completely.
Their signature menu stands out by offering everything from a mini pita to a giant gyro stuffed with premium marinated meats.
I also love that the kitchen bakes specialty cheesecakes and homemade baklava in-house to round out your dinner.
On the downside, the seasoning can sometimes lean salty depending on the day. Tableside service can also feel a bit sparse when the dining room fills up.
But the from-scratch cooking and custom gyro sizes still make it an easy recommendation.
Customer Reviews
So flavorful with friendly staff
From the gorgeous paintings to the food, honestly 10/10. I was absolutely in love with the interior of the restaurant. I ordered the Gyro Greek Salad, Fries, and Peach Tea. The food was so flavorful and the staff was really friendly. I’m definitely going to be bringing the fam back to enjoy this place.
– Rebecca Leary | Google Review
Very friendly atmosphere
There is not anything here that is not delicious! No other Greek restaurant comes close. The service and the employees are exceptional as well. Great quiet atmosphere too! One time when we went my wife had a headache. The music wasn’t loud to begin with, but she asked them if they could please turn it down a little for her migraine. They obliged without hesitation. Very friendly atmosphere.
– The ToddFather | Google Review
3. Anna’s Greek Cuisine
Website: annasgreekcuisine.com
Address: 7370 Sawmill Rd
Contact: (614) 699-5260
Hours: Monday to Saturday, 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM
Operating locally since 1997, Anna’s Greek Cuisine serves genuine dishes crafted entirely from scratch without relying on boxed items. The founder, Anna, weaves her childhood village memories directly into every recipe on the menu.
You can order everything from slow-braised lamb shanks to savory spinach pies, and an easy online ordering system makes takeout simple.
I’m a fan of how deep their roots in Greece run, which shows in the well-loved spot they’ve built on Sawmill Road.
Just be prepared for a strict policy against side dish substitutions. The pricing can also feel a little high on an off night with a fattier cut of meat. The from-scratch authenticity, though, is exactly why regulars keep coming back.
Customer Reviews
Great for a first affordable Greek experience
Small family owned restaurant with very enthusiastic wait staff. The food was great with just the right amount of seasoning. None of the food was overpowering. The Baklava was fantastic! I highly recommend if you like Greek food or if you’re looking for your first affordable Greek experience.
– Corey Welliford | Google Review
Great food at a great price
This is an authentic Greek Restaurant with great food at a great price. Their salads, dressings, moussaka, hummus, and eggplant entrees are amazing. And their baklava!!! It is some of the freshest and best I’ve ever had. Great atmosphere and friendly staff. And parking is always easy.
– Tool Man | Google Review
4. Mr. Shawarma | Lashish The Greek
Website: lashishthegreek.com
Address: 788 Bethel Rd
Contact: (614) 457-5800
Hours: Monday to Sunday, 11:00 AM to 12:00 AM
Lashish The Greek combines two culinary worlds under one roof, with a menu that offers a distinct fusion of classic Greek comfort plates and authentic Middle Eastern street food.
You can pick up traditional moussaka alongside loaded shawarma bowls during their late-night hours, since they stay open until midnight every day to satisfy your evening cravings.
My neighbor told me their giant group boxes are lifesavers for late office parties.
A downside is the occasional slip in order accuracy, where plates and wraps get mixed up. The meat can also be a touch lukewarm if it sits too long.
However, the unique dual-cuisine variety and midnight hours more than make up for the rare hiccup.
Customer Reviews
A hidden gem with reasonable prices
This is the hole-in-the-wall, hidden gem restaurant we’ve all been looking for. The lemon chicken soup was hearty and full of delicious ingredients. The hummus and pita were flavorful and fresh, and the pasta dish was high quality and amazing. And the prices were reasonable. However, the baklava was non-traditional, and more like crumb cake. The original recipe should not be altered.
– Tool Man | Google Review
Everyone in my group loved it
This isn’t a typical Greek restaurant. The gyro meat is moist, like Salisbury steak. The pastitsio is huge, but they don’t use lasagne noodles. The chicken lemon soup has orzo. The shawarma had pickles. Everything’s just a little bit different. Everyone in my group loved their food and loved the restaurant. My 8 year old said the dressing is fire.
– Chris Burton | Google Review
5. Panini Opa | Greek
Website: paniniopa.com
Address: 4799 Sawmill Rd
Contact: (614) 336-8830
Hours: Sunday to Friday, 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM; Saturday, 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM
Panini Opa blends Mediterranean favorites with Italian street food, which makes it a flexible dining option on Sawmill Road. The restaurant uses a fast-casual counter concept to deliver high-quality meals with minimal waiting.
The menu splits evenly between hot-pressed paninis and traditional platters. I really like that you get premium ingredients picked daily from local markets, which you can enjoy on their beautiful outdoor patio.
However, the spot frequently runs understaffed, which can slow down order pickup. Reaching management about an incorrect carryout order can also be tricky.
For a breezy patio lunch, though, the fresh ingredients are well worth a short wait.
Customer Reviews
Reminded me of home
Great fresh food and service. The atmosphere was nice and reminded me of the Greek restaurant I grew up eating at back home. A classy sports bar with fine dining on a budget, Greek style. The seating is kind of tight and hard. So far I have tried the shrimp pasta and gyro bowl over rice. Everything was delicious!
– Ms SmilesnFlowers | Google Review
Everything was delicious
This Greek restaurant is amazing! I ordered a Greek salad with chicken to go. Everything was delicious! Large portions, very fresh veggies and the marinated chicken was moist and very flavorful. It also came with warm fresh pita bread and Greek vinaigrette dressing. If you like Greek food, this is a great place to eat. I did wait 20 minutes for take out, but it was worth it! Friendly service.
– Kelly Kohli | Google Review
