Claire ThompsonIt can be hard to find the best gift shop in Columbus, especially if you want something special instead of just another ordinary item.
Local shops are great for finding handmade gifts, fun souvenirs, and unique items for any occasion. I also enjoy checking out jewelry shops in the city when I want something meaningful.
Whether you need a small keepsake or birthday party supplies, these stores make gift shopping simple. Here are some of the best places to visit.
1. The Red Stable German Village Souvenirs & Gifts
Website: https://www.theredstable.com/
Address: 223 E. Kossuth Street
Contact: (614) 867-5300
Hours: Monday – Thursday 12:00 PM – 7:30 PM, Friday – Saturday 12:00 PM – 8:00 PM, Sunday 11:30 AM – 6:30 PM
The Red Stable German Village Souvenirs & Gifts is set inside a restored 1872 stable, giving the shop a fun old-time feel.
Inside, you’ll find Ohio-made gifts, souvenirs, and authentic German imports. One of the biggest highlights is the large display of cuckoo clocks and Steinbach nutcrackers.
The shop also has the largest collection of German-made collectibles in Ohio. If you can’t stop by, you can order many of these items online.
However, one thing to keep in mind is that authentic imported gifts often cost more than items at a regular souvenir shop. The store also focuses on traditional collectibles, so there are fewer modern gift choices.
Customer Reviews
This gift shop has ALLLL the unique things
Such a unique hidden gem! (well hidden to me, at least). We were searching for a unique candle for our date night adventure challenge and this gift shop has ALLLL the unique things, especially the cutest pop culture planters filled with all varieties of succulents. Shout out to Noah, who was working that night. He was super helpful with our candle selection (we found a berry candle that was hand poured into an upcycled can from a local brewery) and with a recommendation for a local rooftop restaurant.
- Miiranda O’Dell | Google Review
Super cute historical gift shop, filled with art, handmade jewelry
Super cute historical gift shop, filled with art, handmade jewelry, German nutcrackers, tiki planters, Star Wars inspired items, and friendly staff. Great spot to check out while waiting for table at Schmidt’s Sausage Haus.
- Erin O’Brien | Google Review
2. Helen Winnemore’s
Website: https://helenwinnemores.com/
Address: 150 E Kossuth St.
Contact: (614) 444-5850
Hours: Monday – Friday 11:00 AM – 6:00 PM, Saturday 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM, Sunday 12:00 PM – 5:00 PM
Helen Winnemore’s has been a favorite local shop since 1938, and its long history lends the store a warm, welcoming feel.
The shop is filled with handcrafted American-made gifts from independent artists, so you’ll find many items you won’t see in big retail stores.
Beautiful ceramics, handmade jewelry, and colorful Houston Llew Spiritiles are some of the highlights. It’s a great place to shop if you enjoy one-of-a-kind gifts.
That said, one thing to keep in mind is that the store focuses more on handmade gifts than classic souvenirs or party favors. Since many items are handmade, some cost more than gifts at larger stores.
Customer Reviews
A great place to find original pieces
Such a unique and charming jewelry store and gift shop. It’s a great place to find original pieces and great for the artsy soul. They have a wonderful collection. They’re a bit pricey but overall there’s much value in their products. I particularly like that their products are U.S. made. My husband bought me a beautiful bracelet. I love eclectic and original jewelry.
- Jenny Rosario Actress & Talk Show Host | Google Review
Perfect place to grab a gift for a family member
Wow! What a great little shop in German Town. Lots of very high quality hand-made items to choose from. This would be the perfect place to grab a gift for a family member. They even have a children’s room with vintage style toys and a nice albeit small “for men” section. We picked up some earrings a cute little glass figurine. I thought the value was great for the quality of goods they sell. Extremely nice and professional staff as well.
- Alex C | Google Review
3. Wild Cat Gift & Party!
Website: https://wildcatgiftandparty.com/
Address: 3515 N High St.
Contact: (614) 420-6603
Hours: Monday – Friday 11:00 AM – 6:00 PM, Saturday 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM, Sunday 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Wild Cat Gift & Party! has served the neighborhood for more than 20 years, making it a fun place to shop for gifts and party supplies.
This woman-owned business has unique gifts, custom party supplies, home goods, and fun pop culture items all in one place.
They also carry body care products and bright decorations for many kinds of celebrations.
Another reason the shop stands out is its support for the community. A portion of its yearly profits goes to local nonprofits, so every purchase helps a good cause.
On the downside, the store can feel crowded during busy times. Custom letter balloons also cost more than some shoppers expect.
Customer Reviews
A gift for every occasion!
A fun place to shop – there’s always something new, and they truly have a gift for every occasion! The even offer local delivery, so if you’d like to send balloons along with other items they offer (e.g. a puzzle, book, socks, etc.) it is incredibly easy.
- Megan Real | Google Review
One stop shop for a fun/unique gift
If you’re looking for a one stop shop for a fun/unique gift, this is it!! I knew I’d be traveling through the area and put this stop into my GPS. It did not disappoint!! Super fun stuff, friendly ladies behind the counter…I will definitely be back if given the chance!
- Carlee Fairbanks | Google Review
4. Tigertree
Website: https://shoptigertree.com/
Address: 3301 North High Street
Contact: (614) 299-2660
Hours: Monday – Saturday 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM, Sunday 11:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Tigertree has been owned by a husband-and-wife team since 2007 and is a great place to shop for thoughtful gifts.
The store sells well-made clothing, paper goods, jewelry, and everyday items with a classic style that lasts beyond passing trends.
You’ll also find popular brands like BAGGU, playful Jellycat plush toys, and other carefully picked products that are both useful and unique.
Plus, shopping is just as easy online if you can’t visit the store in person.
However, a drawback is that some small items, like stickers, cost more than you might expect. A few customers have also reported shipping delays or trouble getting delivery refunds through customer service.
Customer Reviews
Best gift shop I’ve been in!
Seriously the best gift shop I’ve been in! A little of everything, so well curated, and even some things I’ve never seen before! Pens, puzzles, stationary, stickers, enamel pins, games, stuffed animals, jewelry, clothes, sunglasses, kitchen stuff, bags, and so much more!!! How lucky we are to have this gem in Columbus!
- Gwendolyn Zaczepinski | Google Review
Variety that I can find something for everyone in my family
I used to work in Columbus and would frequent this shop for gifts. For the past 5 years I’ve been a web customer. They source and curate so many high quality, well designed, affordable items that I inevitably fall in love and end up keeping items I’d intended to gift. They make shopping for gifts for any occasion a breeze with enough variety that I can find something for everyone in my family. Service is fast and reliable. My order of Christmas gifts this year arrived within just 3 days of placing my order.
- christina Getachew | Google Review
5. Golden Hobby Gift Shop
Website: https://columbusrecparks.com/
Address: 865 E Capital St.
Contact: (614) 645-8329
Hours: Monday – Thursday 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM, Friday – Saturday 10:00 AM – 4:00 PM
Golden Hobby Gift Shop is the perfect spot to find unique gifts while supporting your local community.
The shop is run by the city’s Recreation and Parks department and features handmade gifts created by talented local senior artisans.
You’ll discover ever-changing collections of custom woodworking, beautiful ceramics, and other unique crafts that you won’t find in big stores.
The best part is that every purchase helps fund community programs, so your gift also gives back.
Keep in mind that the selection changes often, depending on what local artisans create. Because only a few of each item are made, popular gifts can sell out fast.
Customer Reviews
Fabulous array of locally made, unique crafts
Fabulous array of locally made, unique crafts…..special orders welcomed (see something you like but want a different color). Best deals are greeting cards, jewelry, 18” doll clothes. Located within walking distance of great restaurants in a historical neighborhood! Free parking at rear of store.
- Dianne Battigaglia | Google Review
High quality, lovingly made
Warm inviting entrance. Lovingly made Home goods made only by seniors for anyone to buy. Gorgeous cutting boards, jewelry, cards, oven mits, afghans, quilts, tolle painting, acrylic an oil paintings, and so much more!
You really need to visit the Golden Hobby Shop, to show and honor the craftsmanship of your elder community.
High quality, lovingly made, something for everyone! Fabulous prices.
- Gayle Wanamaker | Google Review
