Devon BrooksA high-quality remodel can transform a dark, unused lower level into one of the most valuable spaces in your home. Whether you want a home theater or are looking to boost resale value, the right design can change how that space feels and functions.
Basement renovations come with unique challenges, especially in older Columbus homes. There’s moisture control, insulation, and potential structural concerns.
That’s why choosing an experienced professional is so important.
To help narrow the search, I evaluated local experts who specialize in basement remodeling. Here’s a look at the best basement renovation teams in Columbus to turn unused square footage into a functional, inviting space.
How much does a basement renovation cost in Columbus?
Basement renovations in the Columbus area typically cost between $18,000 and $75,000, with an average mid-range project landing around $30,000 to $45,000, depending on specific finishes and plumbing additions.
| Project Type / Add-on | Estimated Cost |
| Cost Per Square Foot | $25 – $60+ |
| Small/Simple Project | $10,000 – $30,000 |
| Mid-Range Average | $30,000 – $45,000 |
| Basic Finish (1,000–1,500 sq ft) | $65,000+ |
| High-End/Large Project | $100,000+ |
| 3/4 Bathroom Addition | $15,000+ |
| Wet Bar Addition | $15,000+ |
1. Gates Basement Finishing
Website: http://www.gatesbasementfinishing.com/
Areas Served: Columbus and nearby areas
Contact: (614) 397-7966; [email protected]
Hours:
- Monday – Thursday: 8:00 am – 6:00 pm
- Friday: 8:00 am – 5:00 pm
- Saturday: 7:45 am – 12:00 pm
Gates Basement Finishing is a family-owned business that makes underground remodels easy for homeowners in Columbus.
They bring years of experience to the table and manage the entire project from start to finish. This means they handle the permits and the oversight, so you can avoid the headache of hiring extra renovation contractors.
Their pricing is very honest, and they work hard to stay within your budget. On top of that, they can often complete a basement in four to eight weeks.
However, you should know that they only work inside the home. If your basement needs foundation repairs on the outside, you will need a separate company.
They also close early on Saturdays, which is something to consider when scheduling a meeting with them.
Customer Reviews:
Gates Basement Finishing is simply the best
Gates Basement Finishing is simply the best. Trevor, Tom, and the entire crew were great. We had very specific ideas of what we wanted and they were able to accommodate us completely. If you are looking to finish your basement, this is the company you want. We are very happy.
- Craig Berg | Google Review
Absolutely amazing company!
Gates Basement Finishing is an absolutely amazing company! From start to finish I was extremely surprised on how smooth the process went, and how well the communication was from our project manager. I was able to get ahold of him 24/7 to answer any of my questions & always got a timely response. I am absolutely stunned with the finish product. If you were looking to have your basement renovated, or you are starting a project from scratch like myself, I highly recommend this company, you will not be disappointed.
- Larry Ooten | Google Review
2. DC Homes Remodeling and Renovations Columbus
Website: https://customdchomes.com/
Areas Served: Columbus and nearby areas
Contact: (740) 827-3410; [email protected]
Hours: Monday – Sunday: 9:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Clear communication is usually the hardest part of home construction. This is why DC Homes Remodeling and Renovations Columbus uses a philosophy they call “We Speak Homeowner.”
Even though they don’t have a physical storefront in the city, they are very active throughout the Columbus area. They even act as a remodeling concierge, handling everything from permits to the final cleanup.
A local resident who hired them for a home theater loved how the team followed his vision boards perfectly.
What’s even better is they keep their workers in-house to stay on budget and keep you updated with regular reports.
Just note that their focus is on high-end interior finishing instead of structural repairs. Because of this, if you have water leaks, you will need to hire a separate waterproofing expert before they start.
Customer Reviews:
Friendly, trustworthy, and hard working!
Custom DC Homes helped us dream up the perfect design to finish our basement & in less then 8 weeks, completely transformed an unfinished 2200 sq fr basement to the entertaining space of our dreams! Every one was so friendly, trustworthy, and hard working! We originally received 4 quotes from different contractors but knew immediately upon meeting for our consultation that Custom DC Homes was the best option! Thank you for everything!!
- Jordan Wall | Google Review
Jared and his team were amazing
Thank you Dagger Construction for working on our home basement finishing project! We can’t wait for Phase 2! Jared and his team were amazing to work with. Jared provided great ideas and recommendations to help us stay on budget and get the most for our money in Phase 1. Communication was efficient and timely, the crews were very respectful, all trades kept the work areas as clean as possible, and the work was done in a timely fashion. We can’t say enough great things about Jared and his team!
- Marissa Craddock | Google Review
3. Steller Construction
Website: https://www.steller-construction.com/
Address: 400 Lazelle Rd, Suite 5
Contact: (614) 987-8609; [email protected]
Hours: Monday – Friday: 7:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Steller Construction brings a fresh perspective to remodeling by using its hospitality background to provide a very smooth experience for every client.
They have won 12 awards as the best remodeler in Central Ohio, demonstrating their high level of skill.
They offer full design services so they can handle your project from the first drawing to the final details. They even have their own electrical and solar teams to help avoid using outside contractors.
Their project managers are specially trained for technical work and historic preservation. This helps them balance high quality with smart investments for your home.
However, most of their work is focused on the northern suburbs, so people in the south might wait longer for an appointment.
Also, they are closed on weekends. This can make scheduling a bit difficult for clients who work during the week.
Customer Reviews:
A terrific experience from start to finish
A terrific experience from start to finish. Steller constructed a new, full bath in our basement. Everything was easy from our end, because Bryan and the team were on it. We will be using them again for future projects.
- Chris Sale | Google Review
Cassie always went above and beyond
We can’t say enough great things about Steller! Bryan, Cassie, and the entire crew were always responsive, professional, organized, and detail oriented! Cassie always went above and beyond to source what we needed, and provide reassurance and feedback. We will definitely use Steller again for future projects!
- Marissa Wolfgram | Google Review
4. Columbus Ohio Basements – Water Proofing Service in Columbus Ohio
Website: https://columbusohiobasements.com/
Areas Served: Columbus and nearby areas
Contact: (614) 615-9887; [email protected]
Hours: Available 24/7
Moisture problems can easily derail a basement remodel, which is why Columbus, Ohio Basements takes a protection-first approach. Although they do not operate from a central city office, they are fully focused on serving the Columbus area.
This family-owned company has been operating since 1989 and handles everything from crawl space work to full basement finishing.
Their process starts with addressing structural concerns like foundation cracks and water intrusion before moving on to any cosmetic upgrades.
A colleague of mine used them for water mitigation and found their understanding of local soil conditions especially helpful during the project.
It’s also reassuring that they offer a guarantee for a dry, moisture-controlled result to help prevent mold and long-term damage.
Just note that their approach is more functional than luxury-focused.
Plus, because they are based in the eastern suburbs, response times on the west side of the city can occasionally be longer.
Customer Reviews:
Monty and his team did a great job
Monty and his team did a great job with our basement. I appreciate the constant communication from when he began to when he ended the job. He also noticed additional problems and gave suggestions to remedy them. I would recommend Columbus Ohio Basements for people’s basements needs and more.
- Cam N | Google Review
The crew is skilled and friendly
Columbus Ohio Basements finished our basement starting from the exposed blocks and ceiling joists to a very nice finished basement. Framing, drywall, electric, plumbing and painting. All work schedules and timelines were met and all work expertly done. The crew is skilled and friendly. Extra efforts to keep area clean and safe. We enjoyed this experience from start to finish and will enjoy our new living space.
- J Kevin Schmelzer | Google Review
5. Homecraft Remodeling
Website: http://homecraftremodeling.us/
Address: 7909 Station St
Contact: (740) 873-7393; [email protected]
Hours: Monday – Friday: 8:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Homecraft Remodeling brings a veteran-owned background to its work, which shows in its structured and highly organized approach.
With over 3,000 completed local projects, they have experience managing complex layouts and coordinating multiple trades.
Their full-service process includes handling permits and working with specialized contractors such as concrete crews. They even arrange professional cleaning and photography so the finished space is ready to enjoy immediately.
They also take early precautions by checking mechanical systems for moisture before any walls are installed, helping reduce long-term issues.
Pricing is transparent too, with no hidden fees.
One thing to know is that they do not offer 3D models to walk through during planning.
Also, they only work on weekdays. This might make it hard to schedule a meeting if you are busy during the week.
Customer Reviews:
They brought our vision to life
HomeCraft Remodeling did a fantastic job on our basement. They brought our vision to life and it turned out even better than we thought it would. They were very communicative throughout the entire process, had a lot of ideas and even provided a consult with a designer. Everyone we worked with was friendly, professional and helpful. I would highly recommend working with them for home remodeling projects.
- Anderonke Ingram | Google Review
Quality of work they have provided us with!
We have used this company 4 times for remodeling our home. Bathrooms, Kitchen and Basement, they have done a phenominal job. We had a few bad experiences with Contractors prior to finding Homecraft so while I don’t leave reviews a lot I felt compelled this time. Highly recommend these Guys based on the communication, timeline and quality of work they have provided us with!
- Joey TheBuckeyes | Google Review
