Claire ThompsonThey say the worst calls often reach you in the middle of the night. So when my friend once phoned me at 3 am after getting arrested, my instincts panicked before letting me think straight.
This was his first charge ever. And since we’ve both been such goody two-shoes (until that point), we weren’t perfectly familiar with how the legal system worked.
He was understandably overwhelmed, but I reassured him that everything would be fine. So I quickly looked into the best criminal defense firms in Columbus and narrowed my list to the most promising ones below.
How much do criminal defense firms charge in Columbus?
Criminal defense firms in Columbus typically charge between $150 and $400 per hour, depending on the charge severity, case complexity, expected length, lawyer experience and reputation, and after-hours involvement.
1. Joslyn Law Firm
Address: 501 S High St
Contact details:
- +1 614 444 1900
- [email protected]
Business hours: Open 24 hours
Joslyn Law Firm is one of Central Ohio’s best law firms. At the heart of it is the lead attorney, Brian D. Joslyn, who’s recognized by the National Academy of Criminal Defense Attorneys.
That recognition comes with versatility—his team offers a wide range of services, from minor traffic offenses and petty theft to drug trafficking and vehicular homicide.
To prepare for each case, we appreciate how they use thorough investigation techniques with former police investigators for efficiency.
It’s not just about strategy either. An anxious first-time offender even told us that he was treated with respect and no judgment, even for a tough and complex situation, which matters when you’re already stressed and juggling multiple hearings.
You can also attend these meetings without added hassle, as their main office is conveniently located near courts and public transportation.
Nevertheless, there are times when they couldn’t reply fast enough with last-minute emails and calls about urgent questions, so consistency with communication varies.
Handled my case with intelligence, confidence, and precision
“I was at the lowest point in my life and facing a situation that felt overwhelming and terrifying. From the moment I hired Tamas and his team, everything changed. They were calm, focused, and relentlessly prepared when I needed it most. Tamas fought for me every step of the way and handled my case with intelligence, confidence, and precision. His courtroom presence and strategy were incredible to witness. Because of his work, I was able to move forward with my life again, something I honestly wasn’t sure would be possible at the time. If you ever find yourself in serious legal trouble and need someone who truly knows how to protect you and advocate for you, this is the attorney you want in your corner. He’s the only lawyer I will ever call, and I can’t recommend him highly enough.”
– Nick D, Google Review
Very down to earth and really cares for her clients
“Madison Mackay was phenomenal as my son’s criminal defense attorney, she explained everything, was with us through the whole process,she is very down to earth and really cares for her clients, Madison worked hard on this case and got us thru trial , I highly recommend Madison”
– Jen Prince, Google Review
2. Luftman, Heck & Associates LLP
Address: 150 E Mound St STE 300
Contact details:
- +1 614 304 3146
- [email protected]
Business hours: Open 24 hours
Luftman, Heck & Associates has been in business for over 2 decades, building a lot of trust in the city. Their founders and lawyers are even recognized in The Best Lawyers in America 2026 for professional performance.
This track record shows in their work, as they handle plenty of minor to serious criminal charges—including federal offenses. Their attorneys also always explain the steps well to avoid overwhelming anyone.
People we spoke to echoed this, as some mentioned how reassuring the atmosphere was. It’s even easier when their location is near the courts and public transport, which definitely helps clients attend meetings and hearings without breaking a sweat.
The only thing we’re worried about is that their small team often juggles many cases at once, causing occasional delays.
Can’t say enough how pleased I am with the outcome
“Ben did an amazing job handling my 2nd OVI, he was very responsive and resolved the case by getting the prosecution and judge to drop this to a speeding ticket – saving me the trouble of license suspension, jail time, probation, and massive fees – can’t say enough about how pleased I am with this outcome ! 10/10 have used prior to this case and would use his office again if ever needed.”
– Sean, Google Review
Great in communicating what was needed
“Ben was great in communicating what was needed and the status of the case moving forward. What I thought was going to be an extremely stressful few months went by very smoothly and with no worry. I would recommend this office for any legal needs you may have”
– Allen Leatherwood, Google Review
3. Bowen, Scranton, & Olsen, LLC
Address: 536 S High St
Contact details:
- +1 614 254 6517
- +1 614 618 0156
Business hours: Open 24 hours
What makes Bowen, Scranton, & Olsen a strong choice is that they’re a highly accessible criminal defense firm, being right in downtown Columbus.
Their lawyers stand out with over 50 years of combined legal experience, making the firm even more impressive. We also think working alongside former prosecutors gives them better insight into both sides of criminal law.
These strategies are usually communicated smoothly, as they keep patrons well-informed. They received honest assessments and easily digestible answers whenever needed.
The attorneys kept this kind of diligence to a wide service range, which includes DUI, felony defense, and sex crimes.
However, one client told us that he waited for a long time before receiving a routine update. This could feel frustrating for some, especially those in the middle of a busy caseload.
Knowledgeable, professional, and competent
“Peter Scranton did an amazing job assisting us and my son the last few months. He is knowledgeable, professional and competent. We truly appreciate all his hard work and highly recommended him and his firm.”
– Gentra Curran, Google Review
Prompt, thorough, and supportive
“Sometimes you just need a professional. I reached out to Peter Scranton about a legal matter, and he was prompt, thorough, and — above all — supportive. His communication was clear, and his patience was limitless. I’m so appreciative of his ability to make sense of a senseless situation. I would (and do) recommend this firm to anyone needing a defense attorney.”
– Stefanie Lorenz, Google Review
4. Koffel Brininger Nesbitt
Address: 1801 Watermark Dr #350
Contact details:
- +1 614 360 1155
- +1 614 884 1100
Business hours: Daily: 7:00 am – 10:00 pm
Koffel Brininger Nesbitt delivers top-notch results year after year, as they’re part of The Best Lawyers in America every year since 2008 and have been named one of the Top 10 Criminal Defense Attorneys in Ohio.
That level of expertise is handy, with the staff working on many criminal defense cases. They’re also skilled in dealing with numerous stressful legal battles like DUI defenses and felony assaults, which shows in their incredible communication.
For one, individuals we interviewed were welcome to text or email the attorneys and staff at any time—let it be evenings or weekends.
The crew even offers same-day and next-day appointments, speeding up case momentum and cutting down time for making critical decisions.
If you plan on visiting, their central location comes with easy parking. You’ll still need a car for in-person meetings since there are limited transit options around.
And as you know, they’re a nationally ranked firm with highly reputable lawyers. This means steeper costs even for minor cases.
I couldn’t be happier with my outcome
“Great firm, I highly recommend..I couldn’t be happier with my outcome. I had the help of Will Nesbitt..I know trying to find a lawyer can be stressful. I called this firm and they got things moving and grooving asap. Brandi was so kind when I called frazzled & upset. If you’re looking for some legal help, give them a call first you won’t be disappointed…”
– Ashley Steele, Google Review
Professional, kind, non-judgmental, and supportive
“The entire staff at KBN, especially my lawyer Tess, was awesome! They were patient and walked me through the entire process and was with me every step of the way, from my initial arraignment all the way through my judicial release. Throughout the entire process, they were professional, kind, non-judgmental, and supportive. I heard many horror stories of lawyers that are hard to reach, “take the money and run,” and so forth… these are NOT these types of lawyers! If you’re looking for a law firm that will be at your side, support you, and guide you through your darkest moments look no further than KBN!!!!”
– Eric R., Google Review
5. Riddell Law LLC
Address: 1335 Dublin Rd #220a
Contact details:
- +1 614 361 2804
- [email protected]
Business hours:
- Mon-Fri: 7:00 am – 7:00 pm
- Sat-Sun: 7:00 am – 5:00 pm
Given that Riddell Law has a focused niche in minor criminal defense cases like DUI and domestic violence misdemeanors, they showcase a strong understanding of local municipal and mayor’s courts.
We think this specialization pays off in professional recognition. Their founder has even been named a “Rising Star” by Ohio SuperLawyers and a Top Lawyer by Columbus CEO Magazine multiple times.
Those we spoke with also commended the team for being knowledgeable. They were given quick and clear updates, reassuring them a lot.
Many of these happy clients have no problem visiting frequently, either, probably due to the office being relatively close to the city’s suburbs.
Just keep in mind that this firm doesn’t handle major felonies, such as sexual assault or drug trafficking. This narrow scope makes them unsuitable for more complex or high-profile cases.
Professional, knowledgeable, and made the whole process stress-free
“Riddle Law Firm did an amazing job helping me with a hazmat load ticket in Ohio. They were professional, knowledgeable, and made the whole process stress-free. Truly fantastic service—highly recommend!”
– Garry Samra, Google Review
Excellent communication and very fair prices
“Doug got my case dismissed, only had to pay a small fine. 10/10 would 100% recommend you hire him for any traffic related offense! Excellent communication and his prices were very fair and considerably a lot less than others out there.”
– Jordan Taylor (AlmightyJBizzle), Google Review
