Jordan EllisWe once handled branding for a small business, and one major issue kept coming up—the logo and visuals looked different across all platforms. The colors weren’t consistent, the font kept changing, and the overall design made the brand feel unpolished.
We tried fixing it ourselves using design tools and templates. It worked at first, but the inconsistency became more obvious, especially on social media and marketing materials.
That’s when we started looking for the best graphic designers in Columbus who could create a clean, cohesive brand identity. After reviewing portfolios and client feedback, we’ve put together a list that’s definitely worth checking out.
How much do graphic design services cost in Columbus?
Graphic design services cost in Columbus typically range from free to about $100 to $150. However, costs are influenced by factors like the designer’s expertise, project complexity, and whether strategy or branding advice is included.
1. Slagle Design
Address: 70 Fallis Rd
Phone: +16148046234
Business Hours:
- Monday to Friday: 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM
Slagle Design isn’t a typical template-style studio. What stood out to us right away is how much they lean into storytelling rather than just creating visuals that look good on the surface.
Their work in brand identity systems and illustration-based branding feels intentional, and everything from digital to social media is consistent across platforms.
The process is also a strategy-led one. Instead of jumping straight into design, they start with brand discovery and research, which makes the final output feel more grounded.
We like that they combine logo design with full brand guidelines, especially for businesses that want consistency over time rather than quick design fixes.
They have also built a strong presence in the industry, with recognition from groups like the Columbus Society of Communication Arts and features in LogoLounge and Adobe Create.
But one thing to keep in mind, though, is that some of the websites they have created occasionally have broken links or pages that don’t load properly.
High-quality brand design
“It was an absolute pleasure working with Jeremy on my play café logo. He truly listened to what we wanted and translated our vision into a design that feels modern, brand-specific, and elevated. The final logo perfectly captures the essence of our concept and has already made a strong impression on partners and customers. Highly recommend Jeremy for thoughtful, high-quality brand design.”
- Stella Giambo, Google Review
Took time to understand my vision
“I had the pleasure of working with Slagle Design on my logo and I couldn’t be happier with what Jeremy delivered. He took the time to understand my vision and made the whole process collaborative & fun. The final logo is exactly what I wanted—modern, elevated, and reflected the true essence of my brand.”
- Betsy Hall, Google Review
2. Marcy Design
Address: 347 S Gould Rd
Phone: +16142246226
Business Hours:
- Monday to Friday: 7:00 AM to 7:00 PM
With over 30 years in the industry, Marcy Design is often praised by clients for its reliability and experience. We love that they communicate clearly and are good at turning ideas into practical digital solutions.
Clients also tend to highlight their website design and development work. They often mention their custom, user-focused websites that are not only visually appealing but also designed to drive conversions.
Their production work comes across as polished and consistent, particularly for branding and media projects.
We appreciate their programming and web application services, which are frequently noted for handling more complex and technical requirements.
In SEO and digital marketing, some clients report improved stability and traffic over time, noting that the strategies feel well integrated with their website’s work.
However, one common concern raised by some clients is the higher price point. This may be a bit challenging for smaller businesses or those working with tighter budgets.
Great work
“Marcy Design was great to work with. They helped us through every step of the way to design and launch a new updated website for our company. We are very pleased with their work.”
- P. Groves, Google Review
Completely satisfied with their work
“The Marcy Design team did a wonderful job creating and developing the website for our small business. The team was responsive and easy to work with. They continue to provide support and troubleshoot any problems that arise. I have been completely satisfied with their work.”
- Joel Wichtman, Google Review
3. A Payne’s Designs
Phone: +16144078887
Business Hours:
- Monday: 10:00 AM to 4:30 PM
- Tuesday to Friday: 9:00 AM to 4:30 PM
We recently checked out A Payne’s Designs, and what stood out right away is how intentional and cohesive their work feels. It goes beyond visuals—they build brand identities that stay consistent across different touchpoints.
From social media graphics that match a brand’s voice to bold billboards and event signage, everything feels aligned and purposeful.
Their print collateral is clean and professional, while their book and magazine layout shows strong attention to structure and storytelling.
They also handle more corporate needs, such as annual reports and conversion-focused website structure. This gives their work a more complete, business-ready edge.
Another standout offering is the Brand Makeover Program. It runs for about 3 months at an affordable rate of $3,600, with flexible payment options like installments or buy now, pay later.
However, pricing for other services is not always clearly listed up front, which can make it harder for smaller businesses to plan their budgets before reaching out.
Pros
Cons
Fantastic to work with
“Amber was fantastic to work with and she gave new life to our magazine. Working with a magazine that has multiple stakeholders can be challenging, but Amber helped us get the final product across the finish line and we couldnt have been happier.”
- Michael Tyler II, Google Review
Thorough and attentive
“I highly recommend A. Payne’s Designs. They are professional, thorough and attentive. Our website continues to receive positive feedback on the design and information’s format. A. Payne’s Designs production output is excellent coupled by a reasonable price point.”
- Pamela Wood, Google Review
4. GP Creative
Address: 985 Bethel Rd, Suite A
Phone: +16143980108
Business Hours:
- Monday to Friday: 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM
GP Creative is often described as feeling more like an embedded creative team than a traditional agency.
What stands out is their multi-platform content production, which helps keep branding consistent across channels without things feeling disconnected.
There’s also a strong connection between strategy and execution, making projects feel more structured and easier to manage. Instead of delivering isolated designs, they tend to carry ideas through from planning to final rollout.
Their video and motion graphics work is well-regarded for its ability to strengthen storytelling. Web design and UX-focused websites feel thoughtful and user-centered rather than template-based.
The daily collaboration setup is another highlight, allowing for faster feedback and smoother communication throughout projects.
With over 14,000 marketing projects completed, their experience is clearly established.
That said, one limitation is their limited appointment availability, which can make it harder for new users to secure timely slots.
The team is amazing to work with
“Myself and I on the One Church team worked directly with the GP Creative on a large project called Next is Now. The team was amazing to work with. They were incredibly patient with us, really listened well to serve the needs of our church, and truthfully over-delivered and exceeded our expectations. They were excellent with communication and follow-up and ultimately delivered an excellent timeline on a tight timeline. I would highly recommend any organization working with them in the future. They have a great team of people all working well together like Steve, Taylor, Tyler, Jack and others.”
- Ryan Breth, Google Review
Fast and responsive
“10/10 would recommend GP Creative! They can handle all your needs for design, websites, videography, and more. They are great to work with! Very fast, responsive, able to work through obstacles, & willing to do whatever it takes to make sure the project is fully taken care of. A really great group of people who have a passion for the work they do! We couldn’t have completed our project without them.”
- Olivia Crank, Google Review
5. Ctrell Designs
Address: 3773 Walnut Creek Dr
Phone: +16145322935
Business Hours:
- Monday to Friday: 8:00 AM to 6:00 PM
- Saturday: 7:00 AM to 11:30 PM
- Sunday: 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM
We looked into Ctrell Designs, and what stands out is how straightforward and fast their branding process is. With over 15 years of experience, the focus is clearly on helping businesses get a solid identity without unnecessary complexity.
Their branding packages feel practical, especially for small businesses that want something clean and functional without a long process.
There’s also consultation and creative development support, which helps shape ideas early so the design direction feels more intentional.
They also cover essential branding assets, such as business cards and branding booklets, keeping everything visually consistent.
However, they have limited graphic design services rather than in-depth or highly customized solutions.
Nonetheless, the fast turnaround of 24-72 hours for many services is helpful for tight deadlines, and they’ve worked across different industries.
Chad is really good
“Chad is really good with the quality work he does. He helped me with the business logo & sign and helped me with flyer & banner design. His fee is reasonable and he is very easy to talk to if you need to make changes. I would recommend him to anyone all the time. Way to go Chad.”
- Bhima Kharel, Google Review
Outstanding service
“Outstanding service with a level of creativity that makes the advertising/marketing of your service, product, organization really pop! Easy to work with and always respectful and professional when interacting with the customer. I’d recommend Ctrell Designs to anyone looking for first-class graphics work.”
- KD Gantt, Google Review
