Maya RichardsonAdding a garage seems straightforward at first, until you start working through everything involved: permits, foundations, roofing, siding, and finding someone who can actually manage the project from start to finish.
For many homeowners, it quickly becomes clear that this is not just a small add-on. It’s a full construction project that needs the right planning and execution to match the existing home and avoid costly mistakes.
Whether the goal is secure vehicle storage or a functional workshop, choosing the right contractor is what ultimately determines how smooth the process feels and how well it turns out.
That’s why I scoured the city for the best garage builders in Columbus. Below are the ones that stood out for communication, craftsmanship, and long-term value.
How much does it cost to build a garage in Columbus?
Building a garage in Columbus generally averages $31,339, with typical detached projects ranging between $16,422 and $46,256 based on the overall size and finish level.
| Garage Size / Type | Estimated Cost Range |
| 1-Car Garage | $10,500 – $27,000 |
| 2-Car Garage | $15,000 – $40,000+ |
| 3-Car Garage | $28,000 – $57,000 |
| Construction per Square Foot (Sq. Ft.) | $30 – $70 (Average $50) |
1. Jewell Building Company LLC (Limited Liability Company)
Website: http://jewellbuildingcompany.com/
Address: 3778 Georgia Avenue
Contact: (380) 400-3613 | [email protected]
Hours: Monday-Friday, 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM; Saturday, By Appointment Only
Taking on a garage build feels less intimidating when the team explains what is happening instead of disappearing after the estimate.
Jewell Building Company stood out to me because its crew brings over 75 years of combined experience and puts a lot of emphasis on communication from start to finish.
A neighbor hired them last spring, and I noticed how quickly the project moved once framing started. The finished outbuilding looked clean, and the siding and roofing tied in naturally with the house.
Some past clients also mention follow-up support, including return visits for door repairs after damage, which adds a layer of long-term reliability.
Because they also handle exterior work, that kind of visual consistency tends to carry through the whole project.
The drawback is scheduling. They are closed on Sundays, and Saturday visits require an appointment.
We highly recommend them
The Jewell crew built us an amazing garage! Josh did such a wonderful job managing our project and communicating with us. He truly went above and beyond by doing little things we didn’t even ask for and paying attention to the details. He was always available to answer our questions and respond to our needs.
- Cathy Cole | Google Review
They care about their customers
Eddie and his team built our garage 3 years ago and after a recent break in, they helped us right away to secure and fix our door. They are the best and we would recommend them to anyone! Most importantly they care about their customers!
- Bobby Cheugh | Google Review
2. Franklin Garage Builders
Website: https://franklingaragebuilders.com/
Address: 1864 Co Rd 156, Ashley
Contact: [email protected]
Hours: Monday-Saturday, 7:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Franklin Garage Builders is a good fit if you want a contractor that keeps the sale and the build under one roof.
Their “we build what we sell” approach limits handoffs, which can make the process feel simpler for homeowners who do not want a long chain of subcontractor conversations.
I also like that they can handle more than basic vehicle storage. Their crews work on decks and patios too, so a garage project can become part of a broader backyard update instead of a standalone box in the yard.
The value angle is strong, especially with promotional upgrades like free door openers.
However, they don’t have a public walk-in showroom, so you cannot inspect materials in person before signing. For complex foundatio
I just can’t recommend Franklin more highly
I am very happy with the job Josh and his crew did in building our garage. The quality of the work was outstanding. Their crews were courteous and professional and they cleaned up very well after each day. The job foreman Bert was so helpful and kept us fully informed on each stage of the job.
- Tony Pello | Google Review
I would strongly recommend them for your project
We’re currently wrapping up a two car garage build with Franklin Garage Builders and couldn’t be more happy that we chose them for this project. Josh and his team have been great to work with from the start of the planning phase to the actual build. If you’re looking for a garage build I would strongly recommend them.
- Andrew Hash | Google Review
3. Rick Wheeler Construction
Website: https://www.rwkitchenbathroomremodeling.com/
Address: 4555 Groves Rd Suite 29
Contact: (614) 999-5973 | [email protected]
Hours: Monday-Friday, 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Rick Wheeler Construction makes the most sense if your garage needs to feel like a finished workshop instead of a plain shell.
The company brings over 40 years of local experience. It has a strong interior remodeling background that can be useful when you want insulation, drywall, storage, lighting, or a cleaner finished feel.
I’d keep them in mind alongside other renovation contractors if the garage is part of a larger home improvement plan.
They can also build large pole barns for rural acreage around the broader suburban area.
Their four-step process also makes the early quoting and planning stage easier to follow, which helps if this is your first major outbuilding project.
The downside is timing. Their work leans heavily into indoor remodeling too, so standalone exterior builds may face longer scheduling queues during busier seasons.
Really worked within my budget and timetable
Great communication, always kept me informed of what was going on. Didn’t talk to me like I was a child, but explained so a layman can understand. Fixed all issues that arose without push back and really worked within my budget and timetable!
- Elizabeth Oliver | Google Review
4. CornerStone Garages
Website: https://www.cornerstonegarages.com/
Address: Marysville, OH 43040
Contact: (614) 560-0116 | [email protected]
Hours: Monday-Friday, 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
CornerStone Garages is the most focused option on this list because garages are not just one service among many.
The company is built around attached and detached garage designs. This can be reassuring when you want a structure that looks intentional instead of added on later.
I like that their consulting is hands-on from early sketches through the final municipal inspection. That kind of guidance matters when rooflines, setbacks, driveway access, and usable yard space all have to work together.
They are also a strong fit for more personal uses, like a storage-heavy hobby space or a lofted workshop for woodworking.
The main limitation is availability. Their office is closed on weekends, so Saturday site evaluations and quick weekend follow-ups are not really part of the experience.
5. Steller Construction
Website: https://www.steller-construction.com/
Address: 400 Lazelle Rd Suite 5
Contact: (614) 987-8609 | [email protected]
Hours: Monday-Friday, 7:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Steller Construction is the one I would look at for a bigger, more architectural garage addition rather than a simple storage build.
The company works as a full-service design-build team, so it can handle the concept, planning, construction, and interior finishing without forcing homeowners to coordinate several separate providers.
Their specialty in secondary living spaces and accessory dwelling units (ADUs) above garages is especially useful if you want the project to add flexible square footage, not just parking.
I also like that the team manages zoning approvals and municipal inspections, since that paperwork can quickly slow a project down.
The finished builds are designed with advanced framing and energy-efficient insulation for colder weather.
The catch is cost. Because Steller positions itself around premium custom work, homeowners looking for a bare-bones shed or budget garage may find the minimum project scope too high.
We will definitely use Steller again
We can’t say enough great things about Steller! Bryan, Cassie, and the entire crew were always responsive, professional, organized, and detail oriented! Cassie always went above and beyond to source what we needed, and provide reassurance and feedback. We will definitely use Steller again for future projects!
- Marissa Wolfgram | Google Review
The professionalism and craftsmanship went beyond our expectations
Amazing job by Steller Construction from beginning to end! The professionalism and craftsmanship of your employees went beyond our expectations. Thank you for your responsiveness and attention to detail throughout the entire process. We look forward to having Steller complete our additional home projects!
- Erica Wanek | Google Review
