City Name
Temperature
Home >> Recent posts >> 5 Best Donut Shops in Columbus for Fresh, Creative Flavors

5 Best Donut Shops in Columbus for Fresh, Creative Flavors

donut-shops-in-columbus
We extensively test and research all services we review. Here's why you can trust us.

Menu Variety: I looked for shops with a mix of classic staples and inventive new flavors. A good pastry case needs to cover every craving at the table.

Dough Quality: I prioritized shops that consistently serve tender donuts without a heavy, greasy aftertaste. Texture decides whether a fried treat is worth the trip.

Accessibility: I checked operating hours and online ordering. Getting a sugar fix shouldn't mean jumping through logistical hoops.

Atmosphere and Value: I favored spots with memorable visual appeal and strong community ties, and I weighed portion sizes against the final total. A premium price only makes sense when the flavor justifies it.

A craving for a massive apple fritter or a perfectly glazed ring doesn’t keep a schedule, whether you’re an Ohio State University student pulling an all-nighter or a weekend brunch fan.

That’s why I compared Columbus donut shops, from late-night counters to artisan spots, on menu variety, dough quality, accessibility, atmosphere and value.

Here are the best donut shops in Columbus for every kind of sugar craving.

How much do donuts cost in Columbus?

Donuts in Columbus typically cost $1.79 to $2.50 for a standard donut and $2.85 to $5.50+ for a specialty one, with a traditional dozen running $18 to $25.

Item typeAverage price rangeIdeal for
Standard individual donut$1.79 to $2.50Quick morning sugar cravings
Specialty individual donut$2.85 to $5.50+Artisanal pastry fans
Traditional dozen$18.00 to $25.00Casual office meetings
Designer dozen$26.00 to $38.00+Upscale weekend brunches
Mini donuts (dozen)$5.00Snackers at events

1. Buckeye Donuts

buckeye-donuts

Website: buckeyedonuts.com

Address: 1998 N High St

Contact: (614) 291-3923

Hours: Open 24/7

Late-night cravings hit hard when you’re cramming for exams or wrapping up a late shift. Buckeye Donuts is a campus institution that never closes, so classic glazed rings and savory Greek diner food are there whenever you need them.

That crossover menu means you can order a peanut butter-filled donut and a hot gyro at three in the morning. 

On top of that, delivery apps make it easy to get an apple fritter without leaving the couch.

They’ve operated since 1969, so the bustling, nostalgic atmosphere is the real thing, not something a chain can copy.

The catch is that the menu relies on traditional wheat and dairy ingredients, so vegan and gluten-free diners will find little made for them in the display case.

Pros

  • Open 24 hours a day
  • Greek diner food alongside donuts
  • Vintage atmosphere since 1969
  • Delivery through apps

Cons

  • Few vegan or gluten-free options

Customer Reviews

Fresh Donuts, Great Food, Friendly Vibes

Buckeye Donuts is such a great Columbus spot! The food is delicious, the donuts are always fresh, and there are so many options to choose from. The staff is friendly and the atmosphere is casual and welcoming. It’s a perfect place to stop for breakfast, a late-night bite, or something sweet. Definitely a Columbus classic!

Kyridou Maria | Google Review

26 Years of Never Letting Me Down!

I’ve come here on and off for over 20 years. Ever since I was a student at Ohio State. This place not only brings back college memories, it always has great food, donuts & coffee. In over 26 years it has never let me down.

Brad W | Google Review

2. Amy’s Donuts

amy-s-donuts

Website: amysdonuts.com

Address: 650 Georgesville Rd

Contact: (614) 641-7721

Hours: Open 24/7

With over 150 oversized gourmet donuts in a brightly colored shop, choosing is half the fun. Amy’s Donuts makes it even better by letting you pick how much filling goes into your pastry at the counter.

Unconventional toppings like breakfast cereal and bacon keep families coming back, and kids get a kick out of the bright interior. 

The staff also makes every donut from scratch, so each one tastes fresh and satisfying.

On top of that, budget-friendly donut holes keep the bill low when you’re feeding a large group. 

The catch is that large custom orders need at least one night of advance notice, so you can’t walk in for office or party boxes.

Pros

  • 150+ gourmet flavors
  • Custom filling at the counter
  • Family-friendly atmosphere
  • Budget-friendly donut holes

Cons

  • Large custom orders need advance notice

Customer Reviews

Freshly Made to Order at 6:00 AM!

Arrived at 6:00a.m when doors opened to dinning room. Came in to order a dozen donuts for my daughters bday. Upon arrival several donuts were not in the case staff was amazing and made to order all donuts that I requested. Donuts were fresh and delicious! Would highly recommend

Renee Jones | Google Review

Awesome Donuts and Awesome Service!

One of the best vanilla cream stick donuts I ever had in my life! This place has awesome service as well as awesome donuts 🍩!!!!! Highly recommend to stop here to get a sweet treat! 🍩 🍩 🍩

Mitch W. | Google Review

3. HoneyDip Donuts & Diner

honeydip-donuts-diner

Website: honeydipdonutsdiner.com

Address: 4480 Kenny Rd

Contact: (614) 459-0812

Hours: Wednesday to Saturday, 6:00 AM to 2:30 PM | Sunday, 7:00 AM to 2:30 PM | Monday and Tuesday closed

A full breakfast menu alongside scratch-made pastries can completely change your weekend brunch plans. You can order omelets and hash browns at any point while they’re open, which suits a lazy weekend brunch. 

HoneyDip Donuts & Diner merges a vintage diner with an old-school bakery, so you can swap hamburger buns for grilled glazed rings and build sweet-and-savory sandwiches.

The staff makes every pastry fresh in-house daily, which gives the donuts a comforting, home-baked taste you’d usually look for at bakeries in Columbus.

Plus, photos of neighborhood regulars cover the walls and add to the authentic diner charm.

Unfortunately, the doors close by 2:30 PM every afternoon and the shop is shut on Mondays and Tuesdays, so busy professionals have to fit a visit into a short window.

Pros

  • Full breakfast menu
  • Sweet-and-savory donut sandwiches
  • Fresh pastries made daily
  • Vintage diner atmosphere

Cons

  • Closed Mondays, Tuesdays and after 2:30 PM

Customer Reviews

Great Food, Sweet Treats, and Friendly Vibes

Honey Dip Donuts & Diner is such a great local spot! The food is delicious. The staff is friendly, welcoming, and makes you feel right at home. I also love the classic diner atmosphere—it’s cozy, casual, and perfect for breakfast or a quick stop for something sweet. Definitely a place I would recommend and come back to!

Kyridou Maria | Google Review

My Favorite Donut Spot in the City!

Love this small old school diner. They have the best cream filled maple iced long john’s in the city! By far my favorite donut to get in Columbus. Devil’s Food chocolate is also a winner!

Hannah Boley | Google Review

4. Donna’s Delicious Dozen

donna-s-delicious-dozen

Website: donnasdeliciousdozen.com

Address: 5322 N Hamilton Rd

Contact: (614) 245-4859

Hours: Tuesday to Friday, 7:00 AM to 1:00 PM | Saturday and Sunday, 8:00 AM to 1:00 PM | Monday closed

Most donuts sit in a glass case for hours before you get them. Donna’s Delicious Dozen skips the case and serves their signature cake base piping hot and made to order.

This proudly Black-owned and woman-owned local business lets you choose every detail of your treat, with an extensive selection of custom icings and crunchy toppings.

They also run a mobile food truck that caters corporate events across the city, a fun alternative to the usual catering services in Columbus.

A friend who manages a local digital marketing agency hired the truck for a recent company retreat, and getting a fresh donut straight from the fryer changed how I think about traditional baked goods. 

The catch is that the shop itself closes at 1:00 PM every day and stays closed on Mondays, so getting a made-to-order donut means planning a morning visit.

Pros

  • Hot, made-to-order donuts
  • Custom icings and toppings
  • Mobile truck catering
  • Corporate event experience

Cons

  • Closes at 1:00 PM daily; closed Mondays

Customer Reviews

Warm, Delicious, and a Huge Party Hit!

First time going to Donna’s. My daughter wanted donuts for her graduation party. We were easily able to place order and get exactly what she wanted. Pick up easy and on time warm at pick up. The donuts were a hit. Everyone loved them! Especially the kiddos with the fruity pebbles. Delicious!! Top it off black owned!! Thank you Donna’s Delicious Dozen!!

Kalifa Johnson | Google Review

Sweet Service and Yummy Custom Donuts

The young woman making the donuts was very precious and sweet and helpful! Donuts were very yummy! Simple cake donut, but made fresh and hot; I made my own (maple icing, honey drizzle, streusel and PB cup). Also tried a white cream filled with chocolate icing – loved it! Simple, but the icings were VERY fresh and I love that they fill a cake donut!

Stefania I | Google Review

5. Destination Donuts

destination-donuts

Website: destinationdonuts.com

Address: 3519 N High St

Contact: [email protected] 

Hours: Monday to Sunday, 7:00 AM to 3:00 PM

Finding a vegan donut that wins over a traditionalist is harder than it sounds. Founder Heather Morris does exactly that at Destination Donuts, with an entirely vegan menu and dense, yeast-raised dough.

The lineup keeps changing too, since premium scratch-made ingredients drive imaginative flavors like apricot pistachio or red raspberry hibiscus on the daily menu board.

On top of that, each donut is big enough to feel like a satisfying meal, so one with a cup of locally brewed coffee can replace a full breakfast.

The downside is that they shut the doors the moment they run out of inventory, so if you arrive late in the afternoon hoping for a specific flavor, you’ll likely find an empty case.

Pros

  • Fully vegan pastries
  • Creative rotating flavors
  • Filling yeast-raised donuts
  • Scratch-made ingredients

Cons

  • Closes as soon as they sell out

Customer Reviews

A Local Donut Shop Like No Other!

A local donut shop like no other! They offer a different assortment of insane flavor concoctions of donuts everyday, with vegan options as well! I haven’t found a donut yet that they have made that isn’t just simply delicious!! But don’t expect boring pedestrian donut offerings, they have donuts that are not just beautiful to look at but brilliant combinations. Lemon raspberry, hibiscus, s’mores donut with homemade marshmallow! Oh my!!!

Joseph Cabalquinto | Google Review

Clean Store, Friendly Staff, and Amazing Donuts

We had the Lemon Blueberry, Apple Cinnamon Spice, and the Maple Pecan. Every one of the donuts were delicious! Admittedly I had really wanted a preserve or fruit filled flavor, but none were available the day we visited. It’s always a relief (as a vegan) to be able to order anything on the menu without reservation. Beautiful and clean store. Very friendly .

Casey Planck | Google Review