Jordan EllisIsn’t it every business owner’s dream for their brand to get noticed by their target audience or customers? To see their brilliant ideas and products marketed or promoted in the right way, yielding the desired results afterward?
I’m sure there’s something incredibly rewarding in having all your hard work out in the world, getting the recognition it deserves. But you know, even the most successful solo entrepreneurs didn’t do it alone.
And that’s why we have the best marketing agencies in Columbus, anyway. To lend you a set of helping hands to make sure your brand’s name appears on people’s search results, bookmarked on browsers, and most importantly, remembered by clients!
How much does hiring a marketing agency cost in Columbus?
Hiring a marketing agency in Columbus costs $1,800 to $6,000 per month, with the average monthly cost being closer to $3,500. Factors affecting the cost include the scope of services, the agency’s experience, and your specific business needs.
1. FYVE Marketing
Address: 875 N High St 4th floor Suite 53
Phone: +1 614 362 4480
Business hours: Monday-Friday, 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM
Businesses such as law firms, guesthouses, and hair salons have all benefited from FYVE Marketing’s services. Clients are happy that their web design and social media ad campaigns were able to turn traffic into sales and leads fast.
With no contracts, they’ll regularly communicate the steps they’re taking to grow your brand. Business owners especially appreciate this, noting that the experienced team is very responsive and easy to talk to when sharing their ideas.
FYVE’s strategic Local PR services also effectively tell your brand’s story to the local audience. However, changes in approach midway, such as shifting from community involvement to influencer endorsements, have left some clients confused about the original direction.
On the bright side, many are grateful for their content and email marketing that helped them win lifelong customers. On top of that, they assist you in crafting (if you haven’t already) a message that resonates with your brand and target audience.
Helped me generate more traffic to my pages
“Caitlin completely transformed my google business profile and business page to help me generate more traffic to my pages and bring in more clients! I cannot thank her enough for all her amazing ideas she had to help me as a small business! 10/10 recommend!”
- Alycia Moreo, Google Review
Built our website and vastly improved it
“Caitlin and her team are top notch. We lucked out by finding them here locally. They have built our website and vastly improved it. She is very responsive, which is huge. They are experts for sure. Happy to partner with them!”
- Chad Kelly, Google Review
2. Sixth City Marketing
Address: 35 E Gay St #324
Phone: +1 614 404 5414
Business hours: Monday-Friday, 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM
An ROI (Return on Investment)-focused SEO agency, Sixty City Marketing’s clients have seen an increase in the profitability of their business’s online presence. They are now ranking higher in search results and gaining more qualified website traffic, thanks to Sixty City’s strategies.
This agency begins by analyzing your target audience’s online behavior, assessing your current performance, and then finally setting realistic marketing goals. Clients like this thoughtful, low-pressure start that makes them feel understood and supported.
But it doesn’t stop there—only then will they craft and execute a fully customized online marketing strategy. And they’ll pattern it based on what you choose from their SEO, Pay-Per-Click Marketing, Web Design & Development, and Social Media Marketing services.
Out of all the businesses they’ve worked with over the years, a few have shared that it took them months to see noticeable results. Some in manufacturing, e-commerce, dental, and finance were okay with the slower turnaround, but others weren’t as pleased.
Strategic approach and transparent communication
“If you’re a business owner in Columbus searching for a reliable and results-driven SEO agency, look no further than Sixth City Marketing. From the moment I contacted them, I knew I was in good hands. John himself is a knowledgeable and passionate SEO expert who took the time to understand my specific needs and goals. Here’s why I highly recommend John’s Columbus SEO services: Strategic approach: They didn’t just throw generic tactics at my website. Instead, they conducted a thorough analysis and developed a customized plan tailored to my industry and target audience. Transparent communication: I was always kept in the loop about their progress and strategies. John regularly provided detailed reports and explained the reasoning behind each action.”
- Ryan Maxey, Google Review
Massive improvements to our keyword rankings
“Sixth City has helped our SEO greatly. We have seen massive improvements to our keyword rankings and organic traffic to our site. Highly recommend.”
- Mike Kubinski, Google Review
3. The Media Captain
Address: 394 E Town St
Phone: +1 614 564 9313
Business hours: Monday-Friday, 8:30 AM to 5:00 PM
The Media Captain charts its course with two main service sails: Development & Design and Marketing. The first covers web design, graphic design, and user experience, while the second includes SEO, paid advertising, email marketing, and social media.
Although some clients love that this makes them a one-stop shop for all their business needs, others find it a bit overwhelming. One shared that it can be difficult to pinpoint which services will actually drive the most leads and sales.
On a positive note, many business owners attest to how the team is genuinely invested in their success. Displaying professionalism and incredible communication at all times, it’s no wonder clients choose to work with them for years.
Let’s not forget that The Media Captain has been featured in many well-known publications like Entrepreneur and The Columbus Dispatch. Owner Jason Parks was also a regular guest on WBNS 10TV, sharing his insights in digital marketing.
Excellent work and communication
“Our team at Columbus Facial Plastics has been working with The Media Captain for the last several years, and it has been a fantastic experience. Their work and their communication are excellent!”
- Steve Nogan, Google Review
Sensibly priced and high-performing digital marketing campaigns
“We are a Private Equity-backed commercial landscaping platform and have appreciated The Media Captain’s insight, guidance and output as we have grown our portfolio. Specifically, over the past 18 months, I’ve had the pleasure of managing our relationship with TMC and believe they are an exceptional agency led by founders, Stefanie and Jason. TMC is accountable to their clients, creating high-performing digital marketing campaigns that are sensibly priced, and ranging from expert web site redesign to high-performing SEO and Pay-Per-Click (PPC) campaigns. TMC will continue to serve our organization as a trusted digital marketing partner based on their track record of trust, established best practices and lead-by-example approach to getting the job done. I highly recommend TMC for similar future engagements.”
- Jim Engineer, Google Review
4. Two Wheels Marketing
Address: 875 N High St 4th floor
Phone: +1 614 440 4020
Business hours: Monday-Friday, 8:00 AM to 5:30 PM
Partnering with Two Wheels Marketing means you get to be part of their three-phase process. Phase 1, ‘Attract Traffic & Expand Reach,’ is praised by clients for driving high-quality traffic that really generates leads and attracts relevant customers.
Meanwhile, their team uses data analysis and user behavior research in Phase 2, ‘Engage Users & Build Trust.’ Lastly, in Phase 3, ‘Convert Users Into Customers’, they work with you to improve your internal sales process, from sales intake to email marketing campaigns.
Two Wheels also follows a growth formula, which says ‘Expand + Persuade + Optimize = Revenue.’ While it’s worked well for many clients, a few felt that it lacked customization and relied too much on standardized packages.
The upside is that business owners like how they’re always informed with regular updates and detailed reports. Even in challenging situations, like unsatisfactory conversion rates, the team is said to have a smart approach with the client’s best interests in mind.
The digital marketing solutions my business has been waiting for
“I’ve worked with Mark and Ryan at Two Wheels for five months. I have nothing but great things to say about both of them. Their service is outstanding. Anytime I have a question, they get back to me right away. They are both very friendly and pleasant to work with. In addition to this, and most importantly, they are SUPER effective. My revenue has been up significantly since I started working with them. They are the digital marketing solutions my business has been waiting for. The cherry on top is their pricing is very competitive. I highly recommend them to anyone looking to grow their business through digital marketing.”
- Anthony Chillemi, Google Review
Felt like a true partnership
“For over a decade, Mark and the team at Two Wheels Marketing have gone above and beyond in managing WorthPoint’s PPC and acquisition media, driving relevant customers to trial and conversion. While leading the Marketing team, I loved how easy it was to communicate with Mark and the team. They kept me in the loop with regular updates and were always available to answer my questions. It felt like a true partnership. Two Wheels Marketing is the real deal; a top-notch group!”
- Rachel Sammons, Google Review
5. 614 Digital
Address: 4138 Leather Stocking Trail
Phone: +1 614 315 6344
Business hours: Monday-Sunday, 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM
614 Digital’s web designs are loved by companies like Skeeles Jacobs Law Offices, Ohio Physical Therapy Association, and Megan Melby Coaching. Clients like how they are made functional and user-friendly, completed fast, and reasonably priced.
Another highlight is 614’s social media management, which has helped many in the food business develop a strong and engaging online presence on Facebook, Instagram, and X. On the downside, due to high demand, a few experienced delayed responses to their inquiries.
But overall, clients continue to partner with them for their easy-to-follow communication and patience in requests or questions. This is especially true in their email marketing service, where some business owners are more particular about personalized messages.
Truly represented my brand
“Corey is fantastic to work with! His clear, step-by-step process made everything easy, and he guided me through every phase. He’s also a great human being and makes every interaction a joy. I had been contemplating a coaching website for years but struggled to find the time and expertise to create a professional online presence that truly represented my brand. Corey exceeded my expectations, and I only wish I had started working with him sooner. If you’re considering a website, reach out to Corey today!”
- Megan Melby, Google Review
Love the website with full e-commerce functionality at a reasonable cost
“I strongly recommend 614 Digital for website design and all internet presence needs. Corey is fantastic to work with! He is very knowledgeable, professional, courteous, quick to respond, and patient with requests and questions. After shopping around for web designers and interviewing a handful, I am so glad I found him! I love the website he built for my business with full e-commerce functionality which was completed in a quick timeline at a reasonable cost. If you are looking for a web designer, do not pass on 614 Digital!”
- Jonathan Burnett, Google Review
