Jordan EllisLast spring, it hailed so frequently that it left my roof in shambles. Each time a storm passed, I found new dents, missing shingles, and even small leaks that I couldn’t trace.
I knew it would cost me a fortune to get them replaced, so I made sure to look for the best roof replacement contractors in Columbus.
I’m not just talking about simply slapping on a new roof. I’m looking for a team I can rely on from start to finish, including help with insurance claims and a thorough final cleanup, all handled with care and professionalism.
Thankfully, I was able to find a handful that can do just that. So, if you’re also dealing with storm damage or just ready for an upgrade, these are the ones you can trust.
How much do roofing replacements cost in Columbus?
Roof replacements in Columbus can range from $12,000 to $19,000. However, note that the total cost still depends on roof size, material choice, and labor costs.
1. Roof King & Restoration
Address: 6155 Huntley Rd M
Phone: +16143798893
Business Hours: Monday to Friday, 9 AM–5 PM
Despite being relatively new to the scene, Roof King & Restoration is already known as a specialist in storm damage in the city. People not only seek their help with repairs but also with insurance claims after wind, hail, or ice damage.
People we spoke with said the team will speak with the insurance company during the initial consultation to ensure the people receive the coverage they deserve.
When it comes to their actual work, they always start with a thorough inspection to assess damage or aging, so they can help homeowners understand their options.
One thing that really sealed the deal for us is that they handle everything from the paperwork and permits, all the way to the final cleanup. From the initial consultation to installation, the process can take 4-6 weeks.
They are pretty flexible with payments as well. You can pay in full or opt for their installment plans starting at $47 a month.
One thing to keep in mind, though, is that communication can be difficult during that waiting period before the installation starts. Occasionally, they don’t answer calls or make clients wait for weeks for updates.
My roof looks great and does not leak anymore
“Benni, the resolution specialist at Roof King Restoration, did an awesome job working with my insurance company to get my roof replaced after a storm. Roof King did a wonderful job, and my roof looks great and does not leak anymore. I highly recommend using Roof King for all your construction needs. Thanks, guys!”
- Jeff Johnson, Google Review
I had an A++ experience with this roofing company
“I had an A++ experience with this roofing company. From start to finish, they made everything incredibly easy and stress-free. Jared was especially great to work with — very professional, responsive, and knowledgeable. He walked me through the entire process and ensured everything was done on time while keeping me updated throughout. The roof was completed efficiently and looks amazing. Highly recommend them if you’re looking for a trustworthy and top-quality roofing team!”
- Colin Ralston, Google Review
2. Home Genius Exteriors
Address: 4889 Sinclair Rd, Suite 202
Phone: +17408833921
Business Hours: Monday to Sunday, 8 AM–9 PM
Alongside roof replacements, Home Genius Exteriors also handles window installations, gutter replacements, and attic insulation. This means the team is an ideal option if you’re planning for a total exterior upgrade.
That said, roofing is where most clients first get to know the company, especially for full replacements. People love that once the team steps in, everything is taken care of. These include the permits, material deliveries, and even the cleanup after the job.
And as a certified Owens Corning contractor, one of only 1% nationwide, they exclusively use the Owens Corning Total Protection Roofing System.
This gives homeowners a high-performance roof that’s fully engineered to seal, defend, and protect against harsh conditions.
From the initial consultation to the installation, the project timeline spans about 2-3 weeks. However, the actual installation only takes one business day, which is pretty impressive compared to other contractors who usually take a week to finish.
However, they do tend to get overly persistent. After the project, some customers experienced nonstop calls from them, even after being told not to.
Extremely happy with the work
“Home Genius was a great experience and did fantastic work. The estimate was done on a Monday by David. He went into my attic and on the roof so he could find the issues. He showed me proof with images so I could clearly see them. Materials were dropped off on a Wednesday. The crew came early the next morning and quickly had the old roof off. They took care of their work and my yard. The gutter was done the next day by a different crew and they had the same high standards for their work and on my yard. Riley came and did my walkthrough and we were both extremely happy with the work.”
- Doug S Otto, Google Review
They are worth every penny
Home Genius Exteriors definitely took care of my roof replacement. Brody educated me about attic ventilation, and although a little bit more money than the other 4 contractor estimates, they are worth every penny! The team was very professional, kept good communication, was here before 7 am, and was done by the afternoon. I will use them again!
- H L Spencer, Google Review
3. Cap City Restoration
Address: 1723 Old Leonard Ave
Phone: +16147496005
Business Hours: Open 24/7
For over 10 years, Cap City Restoration has been a reliable service provider for residential and commercial roof replacements. It has maintained an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, which speaks to its commitment to customer satisfaction.
They install a variety of roofing systems from brands such as CertainTeed and GAF, offering clients options that suit any budget and personal preferences.
Their roof replacement process is impressively thorough, especially during inspections. After the assessment, the team will provide detailed documentation, including photos, of your roof’s condition.
And once the project is confirmed and scheduled, homeowners said that the team will work efficiently to complete the replacement on time, usually in less than a week.
The only thing that put us off was the crew’s cleanliness. For instance, they would leave without cleaning up after themselves and would even leave nails lying around, which can be dangerous.
The Cap City Restoration team was incredible
“Jamie and the Cap City Restoration team were incredible. He walked us through the build of our home, explained the process and materials, and answered any questions we had. We met with a few roofing companies, but felt Jamie’s transparency, quality-assurance, and approach was right for us – we were absolutely correct. The crew completed the entire project in one day and left the place cleaner than they found it! Couldn’t be happier with Cap City and will always recommend it.”
- Jack Ryan, Google Review
The experience exceeded expectations
“Cap City Restorations recently replaced our roof, and the experience exceeded expectations from start to finish. The project was handled with efficiency, professionalism, and care. The team leaders, Jamie, Mike, and Austin, provided outstanding guidance, were consistently available for questions, and ensured that the installation process ran smoothly. When challenges arose—as is often the case with older homes—they addressed them quickly and effectively. Their dedication, attention to detail, and customer-first approach set them apart. My mother and our family are truly grateful for their graciousness and top-level service. I would highly recommend the entire Cap City Restorations Team to anyone seeking top-quality roofing services.”
- Larean Brandon, Google Review
4. The Roof Detective
Address: 4438 Indianola Ave
Phone: +16145009005
Business Hours: Monday to Saturday, 7 AM–8 PM
If you’re dealing with “ghost leaks” on your roof, The Roof Detective is the one you should call. They are well-known for being honest and clear in their assessments, ensuring clients only receive the service they actually need.
They call their process the “true roof” assessment, meaning they look beyond the surface. Part of their inspection is to go into the attic to check for ventilation and insulation issues that might be causing your roofing problems.
And alongside roof replacement, they can also help in the insurance process to make storm-related damage claims smoother.
For a detail-oriented company, their turnaround is surprisingly quick. Once the “detective work” is complete and the permits are in hand, the entire roof replacement is typically completed in 1-3 business days.
According to the homeowners, the team always arrived early and worked quickly without cutting corners. They also kept the site clean and tidy by the end of the day.
But not everyone is satisfied with the team’s services. A few customers reported that communication slows down after the initial inspection.
I was thoroughly impressed with The Roof Detective
“From beginning to end, I was thoroughly impressed with The Roof Detective. I was being bullied by another roofing company when an employee from TRD came to my home, and almost instantly calmed my anxiety. They walked me through every step of the process and fought for me when the insurance tried to deny things. Carrie was able to get my entire roof replaced with barely anything over my deductible. I would 100% recommend (and will) this company to anyone asking.”
- Kim Walls, Google Review
I am extremely satisfied with the whole process
“The Roof Defective was very professional. They cleaned up everything like they weren’t even there. They also did quality work. I am extremely satisfied with the whole process. They completed roofing, siding, and gutters. They handled all the work with our insurance company, too. Our sales rep, Shawn, was a tremendous help. He kept in contact with us through the whole process. He was always friendly and took care of things we couldn’t get the insurance company moving. I would recommend The Roof Detective 1000%!”
- Debbie Anderson, Google Review
5. Columbus Roofing Company (CRC)
Address: 5131 Post Rd #355
Phone: +16147562335
Business Hours: Monday to Sunday, 8 AM–5 PM
Columbus Roofing Company is a locally owned contractor specializing in residential roofing services, including full roof replacements, repairs, and storm-related work.
Their team includes HAAG-certified inspectors, the same standard insurance agents use to evaluate damage. This means CRC is also a reliable partner for people who feel intimidated by the insurance claims process.
The CRC crew is also known for its promptness and high organization. Once the project is approved and insurance claims are finalized, they typically complete the replacement quickly. It could even be completed within a day if conditions allow.
Homeowners we spoke to said the transition from a damaged roof to a brand-new one is so seamless that it barely disrupts their daily routine. Plus, the team maintained clear, consistent communication throughout.
One thing to consider, though, is that they aren’t the cheapest option in the market. You might find their quotes a bit higher than those of other roofers.
The crew was efficient and respectful of my property
“Had an awesome experience working with Jaiden from Columbus Roofing. From start to finish, he was professional, honest, and on top of every detail. He walked me through the entire process, answered all my questions, and made sure everything ran smoothly. The crew was efficient, respectful of my property, and the finished roof looks incredible. You can tell Jaiden takes pride in his work—highly recommend him and the Columbus Roofing team if you want the job done right.”
- Quinn McHenry, Google Review
They did a great job from start to finish
“We couldn’t be happier with everything Nathan at Columbus Roofing Company did for us. He was extremely professional and explained the process so we could understand the steps it would take to get a new roof. The crew that installed the new roofs on my home and detached garage was very professional. They did a great job from start to finish, as well as cleaned up everything very well afterwards. Not one nail found! Nathan was there to oversee the crew and make sure everything was done properly. I would strongly recommend Nathan and Columbus Roofing Company. Working with Columbus Roofing Company took away any insecurity we had about the process, and we will be referring them to my friends.”
- Michael Kovalchik, Google Review
