Devon BrooksOur old house was one of a kind; it was charming and very homey, but it’s way past its prime. Everything in it is basically a fire hazard, and it’s at the point where one wrong step on the creaky floor feels like it will send you straight through the basement.
As much as we loved it, we knew it was time to get some work done. We needed a renovation contractor in Columbus that knows how to make great improvements—and thankfully, we met a reliable provider that made the whole process a breeze.
If you want to make your home feel safer, more functional, and actually enjoyable to live in again, you might find the right team for you in this list.
How much do renovations cost in Columbus?
The cost of renovations in Columbus depends on the scope, labor, and materials. For example, minor home upgrades cost between $20,000 and $50,000. Meanwhile, major remodeling and commercial projects range from $150,000 to $300,000.
1. Elite Home Remodeling
Address: 6295 Busch Blvd
Phone: +13802711058
Business Hours:
- Monday to Friday, 8 AM–4 PM
Elite Home Remodeling is a family-owned renovation company that’s been serving Ohio since 1989. Over the years of its operation, it has earned multiple awards, including being recognized as a top remodeler by local publications for consecutive years.
The company covers a wide range of residential renovations—kitchen, bathroom, and whole-home remodeling. Plus, its comprehensive project management covers an oversight from start to finish, including permitting and design.
Many homeowners find this a huge relief, citing that it makes the whole process smoother and that they don’t have to juggle multiple contractors for different needs.
Their process starts with a free estimate, followed by an initial design meeting. After that, they will dedicate three months to process all the requirements, finalizing the design, and making early adjustments as needed.
The crew appears to be very reliable and professional as well. Once the project starts, they are punctual and mindful of the set timelines.
However, as an interior specialist, they may not be the best team to call for exterior projects, such as installing a new roof or adding an outdoor deck.
We absolutely love our new kitchen
“We had a fantastic experience with Elite Home Remodeling for our kitchen remodel. Communication was excellent from start to finish, Amber did a fantastic job on the design, and the workmanship and materials are top-notch. Most importantly, we absolutely love our new kitchen. Highly recommend!”
- Ashley Meredith, Google Review
We love the finished product
“We worked with Elite for a kitchen island and master bath remodel. Dave and his crew did an excellent job with the work. They were always professional and paid great attention to detail, and helped with minor design changes that were made in the middle of the project. Amber was amazing in helping us with the design and materials selection and helping us stay within our budget. We love the finished product and would highly recommend Elite. We will definitely have them back for future projects.”
- Geoff Dunham, Google Review
2. Homecraft Remodeling
Address: 7909 Station St, Columbus
Phone: +16146349650
Business Hours:
- Open 24/7
For nearly 30 years, Homecraft Remodeling has been providing Columbus homes with luxury renovations and high-quality craftsmanship. It boasts over 1,500 projects completed and 500+ innovative concepts brought to life.
They are known for their elevated yet functional designs, so spaces don’t just look impressive, but also work perfectly for everyday living.
Unlike other smaller contractors that handle only simple “remove and replace” jobs, the Homecraft team is capable of large-scale structural changes like additions and extensions—basically, from demolition through the final touches.
To do so, they maintain personalized, collaborative project development, where designers and builders work closely with homeowners to ensure they deliver according to the clients’ vision.
While they may not be the cheapest option in the market, they do provide free quotes and discounts for military and first responders. We also appreciate that their proposals are transparent, with many clients backing that you pay exactly what was discussed.
Additionally, the crew is praised for being communicative, clean, and for doing small extras (like installing new lights) at no additional cost.
Made our wish come true in a very timely manner
“Homecraft Remodeling did an AMAZING job on our bathroom recently. We opened a small business and wanted our clients to be able to have a restroom that wasnt rundown. Alan and his team made our wish come true in a very timely manner. We now have a gorgeous restroom that we are proud to have available to meet our clients’ needs. We thought it would cost an arm and a leg to complete but they priced us an extremely reasonable quote and completed it under budget. The entire staff was nothing but respectful of us, our office space, our budget, and our time. If you need ANY remodeling done, home or business, I highly recommend Alan and his Homecraft Remodeling team! Thanks, guys, and we will definitely be using you for future needs. Stay blessed.”
- Marie, Google Review
They were nothing but respectful to my home, my time, and my animals
“I recently had work done on my bathroom and it turned out amazing. I presented an idea of what I wanted and their team went above and beyond to make my dream a reality. The downtime was minimal, they worked very efficiently, and got everything done on time. They were nothing but respectful to my home, my time, and my animals. I would HIGHLY recommend Homecraft Remodeling to anyone with home remodeling needs! Thank you, team, and I will definitely use your company again for ANY of my future needs.”
- Katie Crawford, Google Review
3. ImproveIt Home Remodeling
Address: 4580 Bridgeway Ave Ste B
Phone: +18556372999
Business Hours:
- Monday to Friday, 9 AM–5 PM
For nearly four decades, ImproveIt has racked up an impressive number of recognitions. This includes 25 Consumer Choice Awards and a consistent spot in Remodeling Magazine’s Big 50 list.
We found them to be the ideal option if you are looking to make your home energy-efficient or your space more accessible. For example, they specialize in tub-to-shower conversions and walk-in tubs to improve safety.
They are also well sought after for their window replacement services, offering custom-made, energy-efficient replacement windows that are great for Ohio weather.
Although their scope is somewhat limited compared to bigger firms, they truly shine in their niche by providing a streamlined process and strong product warranties (lifetime warranty on parts and labor).
What we like most is that they make their services affordable by helping clients find the best financial plan for them. According to customers, the team offers flexible financing options and helps them qualify for interest-free terms with their partner loan providers.
Fantastic experience
“So far, I am just writing a review on our fantastic experience we just had with our sales representative from ImproveIt Home Remodeling. His name is Dominic Finch. He is such a personable and kind young gentleman. He is very knowledgeable about everything we needed to know for our bathroom remodel. He was also able to get us the very best financing deal that worked for our situation based on his clear understanding of the company’s financing options available. Thank you so much, Dominic. It was a pleasure to meet you.”
- Russell Dobbins, Google Review
Paid attention to every detail
“Such an enjoyable experience. Our sales rep, Kolton, was very professional and thorough. He was a great listener and paid attention to every detail. I would absolutely recommend him. He was honest and gave many suggestions to us to help us decide what we wanted.”
- Beth Verbeek, Google Review
4. Wingler Construction & Remodeling
Address: 771 S Hamilton Rd
Phone: +17404802727
Business Hours:
- Monday to Friday, 8 AM–5 PM
Wingler Construction & Remodeling has been serving homeowners in the city since 2013 with home improvement services. Among its leadership and team, they bring over 50 years of combined industry experience.
The company has earned an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, which is proof of its team’s high-quality service.
Their scope of service covers both interior and exterior work, such as kitchen transformations, bathroom remodels, roofing replacements, and more.
As certified ProVia installers, the team is trained to demonstrate a high level of commitment to quality and ensure the products are installed correctly. This prevents issues that could affect the manufacturer’s warranty.
This training also shows in the finished work. Homeowners we spoke to said the crew was extra meticulous and completed the project without issues.
We also like that their process and service offerings support clients through every step. They provide free quotes, interest-free financing for up to 18 months, and a 2-year workmanship warranty.
However, a few clients weren’t happy about the occasional door-to-door soliciting.
We have already recommended Wingler to friends
“Our expectation for the work completed and the professionalism of ALL employees exceeded our expectations. From the development of the plan with Glenn Speakman to the development of and implementation of the contract with Scott Simmons to the completion of the work with the contract professionals who treated our home like it was their own, we have no complaints! Even when we made an addition when the job was nearly complete, they did all that they could to make it happen. The work is absolutely beautiful. We are proud to invite guests into our home. We have already recommended Wingler to friends and will continue to do so based on our experience!”
- Gene Harris, Google Review
Very impressed with them
“Finding Wingler to finish our basement was the best decision ever. Very impressed with them. All the workers were very nice and reliable. We will be sure to use them again.”
- Neal Family, Google Review
5. Nicholson Builders
Address: 6525 Busch Blvd
Phone: +16148467388
Business Hours:
- Monday to Friday, 8:30 AM–4:30 PM
Nicholson Builders was founded in 2003 by Bill Nicholson (a carpenter) and Mike Fought (an aerospace engineer). This partnership of over two decades has earned them a strong reputation and multiple NARI National Contractor of the Year Awards.
They offer a whole design-build for both interior and exterior renovations for residential and commercial clients.
However, if you are not really looking for a total makeover, they also have a small projects and handyman division. This focuses on repairs, maintenance, and minor home upgrades that typically don’t require construction permits.
As a high-end company, it has its own team of builders, architects, and designers. Every design goes through thoughtful planning before construction, and this includes 3D renderings to help you visualize the project more clearly.
And during construction, clients we spoke to said the team frequently meets with them to provide updates on progress. Plus, the timeline provided is always reliable.
By pricing, Nicholson undoubtedly sits in the premium category. Most of their award-winning projects feature high-end budgets, such as kitchens in the $100k to $150k range and whole-house remodels exceeding $500,000.
We love Nicholson Builders
“We have had quite a few projects performed by Nicholson Builders over the past couple of years, including the total rebuild of our brick front porch, the addition of a wooden ceiling in our foyer, a shower remodel with new tile, the addition of moulding on our stairway walls and the installation of a stainless-steel shelf on our rear deck. And we have several other future projects that we are planning to complete with Nicholson Builders. None of these projects is inexpensive nowadays, but knowing that a truly courteous, professional and experienced team is doing the work gives you tremendous peace of mind. This is the type of experience you will always receive from Nicholson Builders. From their office staff to their project managers to their technicians, you will never find a better group of people to deal with. We love Nicholson Builders!”
- Nancy Sherman, Google Review
They were really everything we could have asked for in a contractor
“Nicholson renovated our kitchen last year and did an excellent job. They were really everything we could have asked for in a contractor. They offered the full range of services we needed, from consulting on the design to the many skills needed to complete the job with high quality. They communicated the schedule very clearly and delivered on time, all the while being cognizant and respectful of the fact that we were living in the house at the time.”
- Jim Manning, Google Review
